Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 105

After telling Adam everything that happened, he asked me to leave the girls information with him, and that he would take care of it. Then he made me go over some more questioning. It was a little different than normal now that we have more girls testifying. Before we left I asked Adam if he thought this would increase our chances of winning. He told me that anything could happen, but most likely yes. It makes it difficult that the girls didn't come out with their stories until now, but this definitely gave us an advantage. Then Leo whisked me away before I could grill Adam more. It's been very clear that I'm different since talking with the girls. Their stories are imprinted in my brain. I started a group text with them though, and we chat throughout it. It's only been a day though. Less than actually. "Get out of your head Millie." Caleb whispered in my ear.

We have been at the beach house all day celebrating the twins. Finally, all of us are 18. Who would have guessed that Leo would be the baby out of us. He sure don't act like it.

All of us, and our parents have been having a blast all day. At least, I think we have. I've been zoning out all day. I feel so bad.

"I can't help it." I whispered back to Caleb.

Caleb has been up my ass all day about it. When I got home last night, I told Mom, Dad, and him about what happened. So, Caleb knows how I feel. Well, sort of. He needs to chill though. Not even Leo has been on me like he has. "This is your boyfriends, and best friends birthday. Focus on them." Caleb gritted out.

God, he's been real moody today.

"If I did that, me and my four boyfriends would be downstairs naked right now." I gritted back.

"Ew Millie." Caleb complained.

I gave him a smug smile.

"Alright you two." Leo said. "You've been at each other's throats all day." He said as he wrapped his arms around me from behind.

"Well, your sister's boyfriend is a fucking asshat." I said making Leo laugh.

I love making him laugh. It doesn't happen very often. Today though, Leo is extra happy, and I want to keep it that way. It's his special day.

"Me? You're the one zoning out on your boyfriends birthday." Caleb practically yelled.

"And you're the one paying more attention to me than your girlfriend." I shouted.

"Hey! I pay plenty of attention to my girlfriend." Caleb stated.

"Really? Then where is she?" I asked.

Caleb looked around.

"The bathroom." He said.

"You are so full of it. Stop talking to me. Ya know what, don't even look at me." I said.

"Fine by me. I don't want to look at your ugly mug anyways." Caleb said as he walked away.

I gasped loudly.

"Ugly mug? Ugly mug! Just because you have muscle doesn't mean you're cute Caleb! You're just a butterface!" I practically screamed.

Caleb paused half way up the back porch steps. He turned around to face me, but stayed where he's at. Then Caleb laughed sarcastically.

"Butterface? I'll have you know that my girlfriend loves my face!" He shouted.

"That's just her being nice Caleb. Don't be dumb." I said.

Caleb clentched his fists.

"You're being a real bitch Ameilia!" He shouted.

"Caleb!" Mom scolded.

"Funny, I was just thinking the same thing about you!" I shouted back.

"Alright you two!" Dad said.

"Tell your son to worry about himself." I stated.

"Caleb, in the house. Millie... go to the beach, or something." Dad said.

I turned on my heel, and stomped my way to the beach. Leo is right behind me, watching the show, so he followed behind me to the beach. Caleb is lucky that all my boyfriends are on the beach too. Otherwise, I would have followed my annoying little brother right into the house.

"You're not allowed to look that mad on my birthday princess." Leo whispered in my ear.

I stopped walking, and turned around to look at him.

"Tell Caleb to mind his buisness then." I stated.

Leo wrapped his arms around me, and pulled me into his chest.

"He's just stressed." Leo said.

"Stressed my a*s. I'm stressed. How come I don't get a free pass?" I asked.

Leo leaned down until his lips are right by my ear.

"Trust me baby, you get something much better than a free pass. Later." He whispered.

That perked me right up.

"All of us?" I asked.

Leo nodded.

"With no punishments?" I asked hopeful.

Leo laughed.

"Well, that depends. You better be a good girl." He said.

"I'm always a good girl." I said with a pout.

Leo laughed again. "You are never a good girl." He said.

"I'll be a good girl for you since it's your birthday." I said, and then kissed his nose. "But.. you can still punish me later if you want." I said sweetly.

"Yeah? You want to be edged again?" Leo asked.

I froze.

"Uhm, well, it's your birthday." I said.

I am not a fan of being egded. Don't get me wrong. It was fun. Finally being able to cum after being denied for so long sent me into a frenzy. It was amazing, but not something I want to do all the time. Leo is too mean, pushing me to my limits like that. Still, I'd do it for him. Leo laughed.

"Relax babe. No edging." He said.

"Really?" I asked.

Leo shrugged. "Maybe a little edging. Not like that night though. I will be spanking that fine a*s tonight." He said.

I wrapped my arms around his neck.

"I'll take all your birthday spankings." I said.

Leo smiled down at me. He reached a hand up to tuck some of my hair behind my ear. Leo has been so different today.

"Are you okay today?" I asked him.

"It's my birthday. I'm spending the day with all the people I love. Why wouldn't I be okay?" He asked.

"I don't know. I just.. You've been acting very different today. Not in a bad way. You seem happier. I just want to make sure everything is okay." I said.

Leo gave me another smile.

"I am very happy today. Today is a day to relax. Things are looking up for this case. My family has been celebrating me with all day. And my girl has been walking around in her small bikini all day. It's been perfect." He said.

I smiled up at him.

"Wanna swim with me?" I asked.

Leo's eyes darkened.

"The last time you convinced us to get in the water, you fucked us all." He said.

I sputtered out laughter.

"I'm not going to do that with with all of our parents here Leo." I said.

"I never know with you princess." He said.

"Well, maybe we could do a little touching." I said lowly.

I hope I sound seductive, and not like a complete idiot.

Leo chuckled lowly.

"See? You can never just behave yourself." He teased.

"But it's so much more fun when I'm a naughty girl." I said.

"Yeah? Well, I'm going to tie you up tonight, and gag that pretty little mouth of yours." He said.

Heat spread through my body landing right in my core.

"Kids! Let's do cake and presents!" Sarah called.

Leo and I waited for the others to join us. We were half way to them when we had stopped. As soon as they made it to us, Milo slung his arm around my shoulders.

"You better behave tonight. I want to tie you up more than anything." Milo said.

I scoffed at him. "The last time I was naughty, you started it. You were the one that untied my-"

Milo put his hand over my mouth to stop me.

"You're going to give me a boner if you finish that sentence." He said.

I smirked under his hand. Milo looked deep into my eyes. I see the heat in his. I've got him.

"Oookay, I'm taking her now." Oliver said. "We leave the two of you alone for literally two seconds, and you're already about to rip each others clothes off." He said amused.

"Are you saying that I would have a harder time doing that with you schnoogems?" I asked.

Oliver rolled his eyes. "You keep using that lame nickname, and I might start punishing you next."

I smiled. "Wow, being punished by your sensual hands.. Okay." I said all dreamy like.

"Babygirl, do I have to throw you over my shoulder to get you away from all this sexual tension?" Atlas teased.

"Please, that will just turn her on too." Milo said.

"True." I said.

"Come on princess." Leo said as he held his hand out for me. "Seems I'm the only one that can deny you." He teased.

"And even that barely works." I muttered.

Leo chuckled.

We walked back to the backyard of the beach house. Sarah had Leo and Lila sit in a couple of chairs at the end of our two picnic tables. My mom brought out the ridiculously large cake that they all worked on together. Then we sang the twins happy birthday. I sat at the end of the picnic table, right next to Leo. Caleb sat across from me. I glared at him for a while. Until Leo leaned to tell me if I didn't stop he would be edging me all night.

Stupid little brother.

Atlas sat next to me while we ate ice cream and cake. I was thankful for that. Atlas is the perfect distraction from my annoying little brother.

"At least you're not zoning out anymore." Caleb muttered from across the table.

"Caleb." Lila scolded him softly.

"What is your problem with me you goon?" I asked.

"Millie." Leo warned.

I ignored him as I glared at my little brother.

"Ya know what, my problem is how ungreatful you are." Caleb said.

I scoffed. "Ungreatful?" I asked.

"Yeah, that's right. You have four guys that fawn all over you like you're some kind of queen, or something. And you just zone out, and ignore them on one of their birthdays." He said.

I stared at him with my mouth open.

"After everything that I told you last night, I thought maybe you'd understand why I'm not all here mentally. I thought that my brother, who has been my biggest supporter for the last year and a half, would cut me some slack. Sorry that I can't pull myself out of my own head after finding out that my ex, who tried to rape me, raped several other girls!" I shouted.

I threw my fork down on my plate, stood up, and stormed inside the house. I didn't stop until I made it to the bathroom. I slammed the door shut, and slid down to the floor. Tears are now streaming down my face.

Did Caleb have a point? Am I being too selfish? Should I be trying harder to be better focused?

This is all too much. I'm scared about this case, about these poor girls. I can't stop thinking about what's going to happen Monday. And now I'm ruining my boyfriend, and best friends birthday.

Someone knocked on the door softly.

"Go away." I yelled as I buried my face in my hands.

"Mil, I'm sorry, let me in." Came Caleb's voice.

I sniffled. "Why? So you can yell me some more about how shitty of a person I am?" I asked.

"I'm sorry Millie. I shouldn't have taken my anger out on you. I didn't mean anything I said." He told me.

"You didn't?" I asked.

"No Millie. You're my sister, and you are a wonderful person." He said.

I stood to my feet, wiped my face, and cracked the door open to see my brother.

"Then why are you being such an ass?" I asked.

Caleb sighed, and looked down at his feet.

"Because I'm jealous of you." He admitted.

My eyebrows shot up as I opened the door more.

"Well, like, obviously, but why?" I asked.

Caleb looked at my face, and shook his head at me.

"You're dumb." He said before growing serious. "You get to go off with all of them. While I get left behind."

"Caleb.. That isn't true. We will still be close." I said.

"It's not the same. I won't see Lila at school anymore. What if she finds someone else at college? Someone older, and closer." He said.

I shook my head. "Lila loves you Caleb. She wouldn't do that to you. But, if you keep being an ass, you are going to push her away. She's worried about you Caleb. Prove to her that you are confident in your relationship. That you know this will work out. Do you really think she doesn't have those same fears about you?" I asked him.

Caleb shook his head.

"There is no other girl for me." He said.

"I bet she feels the same way." I said.

"Maybe." Caleb said.

"Maybe you should talk to her." I suggested.

"Yeah, maybe you're right." He said.

I smiled at my little brother.

"Alright, time to apologize, and give our significant other's their birthday presents." I said.