Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Bonus Chapter 12

Oli didn't have to tell me twice. I eagerly opened my mouth for him. Oliver didn't hesitate in the slightest to shove his entire c**k into my mouth.

I moaned, and drool spilled from the corners of my mouth.

"No fair, I wanted to drool all over him." Atlas teased.

Oliver shimmied all the way out of his jeans while keeping himself in my mouth.

"Don't worry baby, you can suck on my balls." He told Atlas.

"And rub that spot you like." Atlas added.

This is what I needed from them. Well, this and maybe some more attention. This is still perfect. Especially after how I was feeling yesterday. The only thing missing is Milo.

I wish he were here too..

"Oh fuck." Oli breathed out when Atlas started to lick his balls.

After Leo let me cum, I never stopped. Even now I can feel my pussy spasming around Atlas. My orgasm grew even more intense after Leo shoved himself in my ass. I didn't even know that orgasms could be like this.

This is a bit more than any other that I've had. Probably from not getting any for a while, and then being edged in a different way. Plus all of our feelings mixed in with this.

"I'm so happy I came home to this." Oli said excitedly. "I thought you were mad at me angel." He said.

Wait.. I was mad at him.

"Don't you dare stop sucking on him." Leo warned. "Think of this as further punishment. You can be mad at him later." He said.

"What are you even being punished for angel? Did you talk back to our boo bear?" Oliver teased.

I looked up into Oliver's hazel eyes as he fucks my face. Is Leo going to make us have another serious conversation while f*****g? I'm not sure I can do it this time.

"Fuck, I'm gonna cum." Oli said as his eyes rolled back.

"Me too." Leo said.

Atlas held up a thumb's up as if to say him too.

"Let's all cum together." Leo ordered as his thrusts grew faster.

Oliver gripped a handful of my hair as his thrusts grew faster too. Then I tasted it. Oliver's cock twitched in my mouth as he spilled his seed in the back of my throat. Atlas moaned loudly at the same exact time. And Leo jolted, before pausing himself. Oliver pulled himself out of my mouth. Leo pulled himself out of my ass, and rolled onto the bed. I stayed completely still. I don't think I can move.

"That was amazing." Atlas said.

I smiled. It was amazing. I just wish that Milo could have been here too.

Leo wrapped his arms around me, and pulled me off of Atlas. I rolled over, and into Leo's chest. Then sadness started to settle in.

That was the most all of us have done together in weeks. Milo wasn't even here for all of it. This made me feel better for now, but.. Should I be scared still? I mean.. is this going to work for all of us if Milo ignores us? That's our thing.. all of us being in a relationship together..

"What's wrong princess?" Leo whispered into my hair.

"N-nothing." I said as I sat up.

Funny how I suddenly don't feel as weak.

"I think I'm going to take a shower." I said as I rushed to the bathroom.

I leaned against the door after I closed it. Tears stung my eyes. I'm such a mess. How can I even get upset about them all having their own lives? Isn't this what happens when anyone goes to college?

I need to suck up my own feelings, and just be in the moment. For now.. maybe I should focus on soaking in as much of them as I can. Before they all go their own ways.

I guess this relationship was really just a high school fling. I really thought that it would last too. That we would all be together forever. I shouldn't have jumped too far ahead.

Numbly I turned on the shower, and got in. I let the steaming hot water cascade down my body. I need to focus on being happy for now. I don't want any of them to feel bad for how things have been going. Even if they decide to drift away from me. That's life afterall right? It happens to everyone. I just.. They mean so much to me. All four of them. They've been here for me since the day they met me. No matter how much I pushed them away.

They fought for me through the Holly bullshit. They fought beside me through the James bullshit. I owe them so much. The least I can do is try to put my worries aside while I'm with them.

While I'm not though.. I'll just let it all out. Like right now. My chest feels so heavy that I think my heart might explode. There is a knot in my gut that makes me want to throw up. I've never felt this.. devastated before. Suddenly arms circled around me making me jump a foot in the air.

"It's just me angel." Oli said.

I should have know that. I always recognize Oli's touch. I didn't even hear the door to the bathroom open.

"S-sorry." I mumbled.

Oliver kissed my cheek as he kept me in his arms.

"Why don't you tell me what's wrong." He suggested.

I plastered a fake smile on my face, but didn't turn around.

"I don't know what you mean schnoogems. I'm fine." I lied.

Oli rested his head on my shoulder.

"Then why are you crying?" He called me out.

I opened my mouth, completely intent to lie again, but Oli stopped me before I could.

"If you try to lie to me again, I'll tell Leo." He threatened.

I sighed.

"Is this because of that Tristan guy?" Oliver asked with slight annoyance.

I rolled my eyes as I turned in his arms.

"Leo told you about that huh?" I asked lamely.

Oliver nodded.

"Did he tell you the whole truth, or did he just tell you I let some other guy touch me?" I asked annoyed.

Oliver chuckled.

"They both told me the whole truth. Don't worry. And congratulations on possibly being Professor Homak's new TA. I can't wait to brag more to my new friends about my smart hot girlfriend. Well, more than I already do." He teased. I smiled at his words.

"I'm so proud of you Millie." He told me.

I looked up into Oliver's eyes. See, how am I supposed to be upset with them about their own lives? Especially when they're so happy for me.

I can't lose them. I just can't. I can't imagine life without them at this point. I.. don't want to either. I don't ever want to be without any of them. They made me take this chance on them. They can't leave me now. I won't let them. "Whoa, whoa, whoa, why are you crying baby?" Oli asked as he started wiping my tears away.

"Y-y-you ar-aren't a-allowed t-t-t-t-o le-leave m-me." I stammered out.

"What?" Oliver asked.

I wrapped my arms around him as anxiety started to take over.

"You aren't allowed. None of you. I.. can't. I just can't let you leave me. I-I don't care how long I have to wait for things to go back to normal, but.. you can't leave me. You all made me take this chance on you. Now you have to stay, you have to see this through with me." I rambled.

By the end of my rant.. I'm sobbing. Oliver can't keep up with my tears, and it's a muteless point since we are in the shower anyways. So, Oliver grabbed my face with both of his hands, and began placing kisses all over my face.

"Baby calm down. Is this why you're so upset? I knew I should have just came home last night." Oli said.

I shook my head.

"N-no. I don't want you to not do things because of me. I just.. wish one of you would have been here when I went to sleep." I admitted.

"No one was here when you went to sleep last night?" Oli asked.

I shook my head.

"Milo was, but.." My bottom lip trembled. "He told me he needed space, so I left him alone. I didn't even think anyone came to bed with me at all until I woke up." I told him.

"Baby, if I would have known that everyone was going to be gone, I would have came home immediately-"

I shook my head stopping him.

"That isn't fair to you. I'm a grown adult." I said. "It's not.. It's not that I need all of your time, I just.. miss you all. We never spend time together anymore. Leo and Milo are way too busy with school. Atlas is getting all these amazing opportunites with his teacher. And you've made so many new friends. I'm so happy for all of you, but.. I don't want to drift apart." I admitted.

Oliver placed a small kiss to my lips.

"We are not drifting apart baby. I promise that I won't let that happen. I have made some new friends, and they really want to meet you all. I know that we've all been a bit busy, but that doesn't mean we love you any less, or want to be with you less. I do agree that we need to make more time again though. Let's all do something today." He suggested.

"Caleb, and Lila want to come over for dinner." I told him.

"Before that then. Maybe we can get Milo to come home early too." He offered.

I gave him a small smile.

"Okay, yeah. I really would like that." I said.

"Good." Oliver said, and then kissed my nose. "We are also telling the others how you feel by the way. So that we're all on the same page." He said. "Okay." I replied.

"Oh, and I got this for you. It's just metal so it's totally okay to be in the shower." He said.

Oliver bent down to grab something off of the side of the tub. He handed it to me, and I gasped. It's a little metal sea turtle the size of my hand.

"This is so pretty." I told him.

Oliver smiled.

"This is the real reason why I didn't come home last night. Caine made it, and I asked if I could have it for you. He told me I could only have it if I promised to hang with them for the night." He told me.

I looked up into his bright hazel eyes. Wow, I really jumped to conclusions. I feel like an idiot. Oliver only spent a night away from me to get this for me.

"That's really sweet baby, thank you." I told him.

"Anything for my angel." He replied. "Let's get you washed though. I know you're starving."