Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 26

The rest of the week I had rides to and from school every day. Either Milo, Oliver, or Lila. Leo said I wouldn't like riding his motorcycle that early in the morning and I had to agree. He also had things to do every day after school this week. Atlas, has football practice every day before and after school so he couldn't do it. I was thankful either way and they were all pleasant to be around.

Lila and I would talk about the boys, her about my brother. I ended up confiding in Lila about my adventures with all four of the guys. She laughed when I told her I was worried about being a hoe. Lila assured me that if I wasn't lying, then I wasn't a hoe. Same thing Leo told me. So, I vowed to myself to always be honest with them. Lila told me I could do whatever I wanted as long as I stuck to my vow.

Things between her and Caleb seemed to be going well. I know for a fact that Caleb is completely smitten with her. Lila seems to be the same and I couldn't of been happier for her. I told her all about how good of a guy Caleb is and she seemed to believe me. The guys still tried to touch and kiss me, although it seemed to simmer down since Monday. I wasn't sure if I was upset or relieved. They still flirted with me though. And when they would take me home they would touch my thighs and give me sweet kisses. Nothing too intense though. I'm not sure if they're trying to give me space or something but I was beginning to get worked up again.

Atlas called me after practice every day so that we could talk. He said it wasn't fair that everyone got turns driving me around and the least I could do was talk to him on the phone for a few hours. It was really nice actually. Atlas is funny and sweet. He's like a giant teddy bear. I enjoyed our talks and found myself looking forward to them.

Oliver helped me with my calculus and even offered to help me study this weekend. I guess everyone knew about the party on Saturday but me. Oliver offered to pick me up earlier in the day so that we could study before the barbeque. I told him that sounded great, considering I really needed the help.

Milo seemed to know the very next day that my ass was sore. He wouldn't stop rubbing my ass for me all day, unless Oliver was around, then it was him with his hands on my b**t. It honestly felt nice. My b**t was really sore for the whole next day. Milo and I still passed notes every day in history and ignored James. On Thursday James moved seats, finally.

Leo hadn't come over since that first night and I was honestly sad. I wouldn't of been opposed to doing all of that again. He did however, change his attitude towards me. Leo was still mostly expressionless but made a point to tell me hello or goodbye. I was feeling much less ignored by him.

Our group chat is still up and we all mostly talk through that. It was a bit strange to me that we all talked that way instead of them messaging me privately. The whole situation is weird but I kind of like it.

It's now Friday and Lila just pulled into my driveway. "Bye Mom and Dad, see you at the game." I called out before heading to Lila's car.

When I got in I buckled my seatbelt and turned to her. I raised my eyebrow as I took her appearance. Lila is wearing dark blue skinny jeans, with white sneakers. Her hair is up in space buns and she has the school colors striped across her cheeks. I raised my eyebrow at her because she just so happens to also have on my brothers jersey. All the team players get two jersey's so that they have one to wear to school and one to get dirty. Most guys with girlfriends let their girls wear their extra ones. Guess Lila is one of them.

"What?" Lila asked innocently as she pulled out of my driveway.

"Nice outfit." I commented.

"Thanks." She mumbled but I could see the slight blush on her cheeks. "Hey can I ask you a question without you getting offended?" Lila asked.

"Sure." I said.

"Why don't you have your own car?" She asked.

I chuckled. "My dad wants Caleb and I to buy our own. I almost have enough saved up for a down payment but I want to save up a bit more so I can get something really nice. But then I'll have to make payments and such.." I trailed off. "I don't think I will get my own car until after college, but that's alright. Maybe I'll get a car for graduation." I told her.

"That would be cool" She said. "Not that I don't love driving you around or anything. I didn't mean it that way." She rushed out.

I laughed. "It's okay Lila, I didn't take it that way." I assured her.

When Lila and I got to the school she headed to her locker and told me she would meet me at class. I walked to my locker to find Atlas and Leo waiting there for me. They both gave me smiles when I reached them.

"Good morning." I greeted them.

"Morning babygirl." Atlas said with a dreamy look in his eyes.

"You're look hot this morning." Leo commented.

I raised a brow at him as I opened my locker. It's not like I'm looking that special. I'm wearing light blue skinny jeans with a few rips in them. My black converse are on my feet, and I have on a plain baby blue cropped T-shirt. I barely have any makeup on, like usual, and my hair is up in a messy ponytail.

"I look like I do everyday." I mumbled.

"Exactly." Leo said. "I got to go to class. I'll see you guys later. Have a good day princess."

"Bye Leo." I said with a smile. It's weird how things aren't awkward in the slightest.

I closed my locker and turned to face Atlas. He's looking around and acting all shy. He is also not wearing his jersey, but holding it in his hand. I frowned at him.

"Are you okay Atlas?" I asked.

His bright blue eyes snapped to mine. "Uh, yeah." He said and I raised a brow at him. Atlas cleared his throat and took a deep breath. "Babygirl, I want to ask you something." He said sounding like he is faking all of his confidence.

"Okay." I said trying to hide my smile.

"Will you wear my jersey?" He asked.

I blinked at him. That's why he's so nervous? Because he wanted me to wear his jersey? Atlas he staring at me bashfully. His cheeks are beginning to get red and I could no longer hold back the smile that broke out on my face. "You're such a noodle." I said with an eye roll. "Gimme it." I said with my hand out.

"Really?" He asked as he handed it to me.

"Atlas, we made out in the equipment room and you left a hickey on me. You call me babygirl all day long every day. I think that I can wear your jersey." I said with a laugh. "Hold my stuff." I said as I shoved my things at him. Atlas took my things and I slipped his jersey over my head. It's so big that it fell to my mid thighs. I giggled as I looked down at it.

"Well?" I asked as I did a little spin. "Satisfied?"

Atlas was giving me that dreamy look again. He nodded and gulped at the same time. "You look hot as fuck babygirl." He said and then he met my eyes. "But I won't be satisfied until I f**k you in it." Atlas's voice was low and it went straight to my core. I blushed fiercely. "Want to walk me to class?" I asked.

When I got to class Atlas kissed my head before going to his own. I went straight for my normal seat and Lila was beaming at me. She looked me up and down and wiggled her eyebrows at me. I rolled my eyes at her. "We're twinning." She sung out.

I giggled at her. "Shush."

"Is that Millie wearing a jersey?" Came Milinda's nasally voice. "Who in their right mind would let you tarnish their uniform?" She asked and a few of the students snickered.

I chose to ignore her and opened my book instead. Mr. Douglas isn't here like normal but class starts in three minutes. Lila is looking irritated but I gave her a look that says 'it's fine just ignore her'.

"Huh, Norris." Milinda said after she read the jersey. "That big hunk of a man let you wear his jersey? Maybe he doesn't realize other girls exist." She said and I continued to ignore her. "Maybe I should show him."

Those words struck a nerve. I turned around in my seat to glare at her. Milinda looked at me amused. Just when I opened my mouth to tell her to back off the bell rang and Mr. Douglas walked in to start the class. Great, just great. Now I have to worry about Milinda stealing Atlas from me. Well... it's not like he's mine to begin with. I mean, I'm literally flirting and hanging out with all of his friends. Why shouldn't he be able to do things with other girls?

Wait... Are they all doing stuff with other girls? Oh my god, of course they are. I was stupid to think I was the only one. Four guys that all want me and nobody else? What am I, living in a fantasy world? This was an awful idea. All of it. Making out with each other them, letting Leo touch me.. This was just a big mistake, I am literally setting myself up for heart ache here.

The rest of the day I got snide remarks everywhere I went. All because of the jersey. In second period Atlas was at least there to tell everyone to shut up but I was still reeling from Milinda's comments. She's going to find Atlas at some point today and I'm sure he would ask me for his jersey back.

I knew I was starting to distance myself already when I spent the whole class ignoring Atlas. And it didn't stop there. I made excuses in every class to avoid talking to the guys. At lunch I made an excuse about helping Mrs. Gibbson with something. It wasn't a total lie, I did go help her. She just... didn't ask for my help, I offered it up.

Milo tried to pass notes to me the whole class period but I ignored him. It didn't help that James and his stupid friends kept making comments about the jersey. Milo was growing irritated and I was starting to panic that they might fight. Thankfully the teacher cut it all off.

Leo didn't come to our class that we shared and I was thankful. My phone was blowing up all day with messages from the guys. Both in our group chat and personally. I didn't even bother to respond.

Did I really let Milinda's words get to me that badly? I mean, she had a point and it got me thinking. Leo told me to be honest and we wouldn't have any problems, but... Are they being honest with me? I find it hard to believe that they are. Why would four high school boys be competing over one girl without doing it with others? I was kidding myself this whole time.

When the bell rang I walked to my locker alone. Nobody was there waiting for me and I breathed out a sigh of relief. I grabbed all of my things and headed for the library. With any luck I could focus on my school work and ignore everyone else.

Just before I was about to turn the corner in the hall I heard Milinda's nasally voice. "Come on big guy. Why fawn after somebody like Millie Holmebrooke, when you can have all of this." She said and my blood froze.

At that moment Leo appeared beside me. He put his finger over his lips to tell me not to say a word. Then he cupped his ear as if to tell me to listen.

"I bet I could give you better head than her." Milinda said. "I'm sure she's done that with you by now, with how easy she is."

I wrapped my arms around myself and stared at the ground. This is when he tells her 'yeah baby lets go to the equipment room'. My heart dropped when I heard Milinda giggle but didn't hear a thing from Atlas.

"It's Milinda right?" I finally heard Atlas's voice.

I didn't like the soft tone he was using with her. Tears filled my eyes and I felt so stupid. I tried to walk away but Leo wrapped his arms around me and forced me to stay. This must have been their end goal the whole time. Get me to think that they all like me, and then t*****e me like this when someone prettier comes along. I get it now.

"I'm flattered really." Atlas said to her. "But please take your hands off of me." His voice grew harder and my eyes widened. "I'm not into you or any other girl. I thought that by giving Millie my jersey it would prove to all of you girls that I only want her." He said to Milinda.

My eyes snapped up to Leo's. He gave me one of his genuine smiles. My eyebrows furrowed but he only kissed the lines away.

"You do know that nobody likes her right? She's a total loser." Milinda said with a scoff.

"I like her." I've never heard Atlas's voice sound that stern before.

Milinda scoffed. "Whatever, enjoy James's sloppy seconds." She said and then we could hear her storm off.

A few seconds later we heard Atlas's footsteps walk off as well. He must have went into the library. No one else is around right now, leaving just Leo and I in the hallway. Leo's hand came up to grip my chin.

"You weren't starting to think we don't want you were you?" He asked and I averted my eyes. Leo chuckled lowly. "And here we thought we were giving you some space." He said. "Good. Now we get to show you how much we really want you princess."