Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 45

Oliver was successful in distracting me. I was actually super interested in what we are having for food. I'm starving. I was thrilled to hear that we were having pizza. My favorite food, with my favorite toppings, and from my favorite place.

The three of us made conversation on our way to the spot. Oliver parked the car, and told me to stay put. I watched as he and Atlas got out of the car, and walked over to where I could see Leo and Milo. Leo is dressed in his usual black jeans, but his shirt is a nice black button down. Awe, he dressed up for me. Even his curly black hair looks a bit styled, in that sexy messy way.

Milo looks good too. He has on a pair of dark blue jeans with a black V-neck shirt. His light brown hair that is usually up, is now down, and tucked behind his ears. Milo's eyes found mine and I smiled at him. He smiled back and came over to the car. Milo opened my door, and I swung my legs over the seat to get out. I was stopped though when Milo leaned in and pressed his lips to mine. One of his hands came to rest on my thigh.

"Are these the same ones you wore that night with us?" He asked me in a whisper.

Milo has his hand over my thigh high. His fingers are playing with the ends of it. I tried not to shiver at his touch.

"M-maybe." I stuttered.

Milo gave me a dazzeling smile. "You're trying to drive us nuts because we've barely touched you all week huh?" He asked.

I blushed. "Uhm, no?"

Milo laughed, and held his hand out for me. "Yeah okay. Come on cupcake, lets get you fed."

I excitedly let Milo take me to where the others are. A gasp tumbled from my lips as I took in the scene. There is a large picnic blanket laid out. It's perfect for us to watch the sun set from up here. Candles are all around the blanket making it even more romatic. There are a few different pizza boxes on the blanket, with plates and napkins. I also noticed a white box with the label from the bakery I love on top. A bouquet of red roses are laying in the middle of the blanket. And I can see a small cooler sitting to the side. Tears were threatening to come out. This is the sweetest thing anyone has ever done for me. When James and I would go out on dates, it was usually just to the movies or to dinner. No one has put this much thought or work into a date for me. I turned to look at the four guys. They are standing and waiting for my reaction. Atlas and Oliver are looking a bit nervous. Milo is just smiling at me like I was the beautiful sight here, and not the romantic set up they created for me. Leo is just staring at me, expressionless like usual.

"You guys did all of this for me?" I asked.

Milo chuckled. "Who else would we do it for?" He asked.

I shrugged and looked back at the set up. "It's beautiful. Thank you." I told them.

Leo walked over to me and grabbed my hand. He tucked my hair behind my ear. I held my breath at the look in his eyes.

"Anything for you princess." He said. "Now, let's get some food in you. I know you're probably starving." He said dramatically.

The rest of the date went amazing. They had gotten my favorite toppings on the pizza, and even got the fancy bread sticks that are covered in cheese. I finished almost an entire pizza to myself.

"I envy how much you can eat." Atlas told me after I stole one of his bread sticks.

I laughed. "You eat almost as much as I do." I told him.

"Yeah, but Atlas does sports and works out all the time." Milo teased.

I frowned at him. "So?" I said defensively.

"Don't make fun of my angel." Oliver defended me as he put his arm around me. "Yeah." I added like a brat.

"It's not Millie's fault that she can eat more than you." Oliver teased Milo.

Leo chuckled. "I think we all know that Millie never gets full." He said with a wink.

I blushed.

"You look so good with that blush on your cheeks cupcake." Milo told me with a wink of his own.

"I bet our girl is still hungry." Leo said.

They all looked at me, as if waiting for me to answer. My blush deepened, and I refused to meet any of their eyes. I crossed my arms, and stuck my nose in the air. "Nope." I said.

"There's still plenty of pizza." Milo teased.

I shook my head while keeping my nose in the air.

"You want my last bread stick?" Oliver asked.

"No thanks." I lied. I really wanted that last bread stick.

Leo chuckled. "So, you're full then?" He asked.

I nodded. "Yup, super full, won't be able to eat for days." I lied.

This time, chuckles came from all around me. I still refused to open my eyes and look at them. If I did, I would definitely lose and take more food.

"Then I guess you don't want any of these eclairs." Leo said.

I froze. My eyes popped open and fell to him. Leo is staring at me with a stupid smirk on his face. He pulled over the box from the bakery and opened it. Milo looked into the box. "Whoa, those look good as fuck." Milo said.

Leo kept his eyes on me as he pulled out an eclair and brought it to his mouth. He took a bite and moaned. Cream was on the corner of his mouth, and all I could think about is licking it off of him.

Stupid Leo knows that these eclairs are my favorite. The one and only time that Leo and I ever spent alone, we went to that bakery. The other guys were busy that day, and Lila had went to watch Caleb practice. Leo offered to drive me home, on his motorcycle. It was so much fun.

We had went to get the eclairs after I told Leo that they were my favorite. He had gotten me a whole box then too, but I made him take them home for the guys. That was probably one of the only times I have ever shared my food. It was a very lovely day. Now though.. Now, I want to punch him in the throat. He know's he's breaking me down. Stupid smirking a*****e.

"Damn, Millie those look good." Oliver whispered in my ear. "I remember when you had Leo bring us all some of those. They were delicious." He said lowly.

I gulped.

Atlast reached over and grabbed one of his own. I watched as he brought it to his mouth and ate half of it in one bite. He chewed and swallowed it so fast.

"Did you even taste it?" My voice came out more annoyed than I intended.

Milo and Oliver laughed at my little outburst.

"You want one princess? All you gotta do is ask." Leo coaxed.

I chewed on my bottom lip as I watched him take another bite.

"It's okay to admit if you want something angel. We will still want you, no matter what." Oliver whispered in my ear. "Maybe if you're a good girl, Leo will give you what you want." He cooed. "I know you've been dying for one of them to touch you." He said. I shook my head. "Give me the damn box." I ordered.

Leo's eyebrows shot up. Oliver went rigid next to me. Atlas froze mid-bite. Milo just laughed.

"Giving me orders huh?" Leo asked.

I cleared my throat. "Yes. I. Am." I stated bratty.

Leo chuckled darkly and I gulped. Before Leo could say another word, Milo pulled out his own eclair, and then pushed the box to me. I looked up at him and he smiled at me.

"It's date night. No punishments on date night." Milo stated casually.

I frowned, but snatched the box up and set it in my lap.

"That doesn't mean you still won't get punished though princess. I'll be keeping track." Leo told me.

I chose to ignore him, and stuff my face with an eclair instead. So good. I love these things.

The guys asked me if I wanted to go see a movie or stay here. I guess that Oliver had brought his laptop with him just in case. I chose to stay. Not because I was afraid to be seen on a date with them, but because I didn't want to leave this romantic set up. Oliver pulled out his laptop and another blanket from his car. Milo pulled me into his lap, and wrapped the blanket around us. Atlas sat to my right, Oliver to my left, and Leo between my legs. It feels right. All of this. I could deny all I wanted, but this felt like a real date, like a real relationship. I feel more for each of them than I ever did for James. I just hoped that maybe they would grow to feel the same way for me.

When the movie was over Leo ordered me to sit in the backseat of Milo's car while they cleaned up. He even let me bring the leftover elcairs. I was more than happy to finish them off.

After they were done cleaning up, Atlas and Oliver kissed me good night. My heart ached as I watched them drive off. I wish we could all stay together.

Leo got in the driver seat of Milo's car, and Milo got in the passenger seat. I thought that we would just get going, but they both turned in their seats to look at me. Oh, am I going to be getting a punishment anyways?

"Did you have a good time tonight cupcake?" Milo asked me.

I nodded. "A very good time, thank you. D-did you guys?" I asked awkwardly.

Why am I so nervous?

Milo beamed. "Best date I've ever had, and I mean that." He said.

I blushed. "Good."

"Princess, Milo and I have a present for you, but you have to keep a secret from Atlas." Leo said.

I frowned. "Why?" I asked.

Milo chuckled. "Because it's a surprise for him."

"Think of it as a birthday present to him." Leo added.

"Okay?" I said.

Leo and Milo shared a look before turning back to me.

"That bag down by your feet, open it." Leo ordered me.

I reached down and grabbed the small gift bag. Opening it I pulled out a white see-through lingerie set. The top has a built in bra and has a split up the middle. The underwear is a very thin thong. It would go perfect with the thigh highs I have on right now, but I was confused.

"How is this for Atlas?" I asked.

Milo smirked. "Next weekend is his birthday, you know he's throwing a party."

I rolled my eyes. "Unfortunately." I said. "He invited the whole football team."

"Oh, Atlas invited the whole damn school." Milo said.

"What?" I groaned out.

Milo chuckled. "Don't worry. He flat out told James, Josh, and the entire cheerleading team that they are not invited and will be escorted off the property if they show up."

My eyebrows shot up. "Oh."

"Anyways." Leo said. "We want you to wear this for him that night. Sneak into his room before he get's too drunk. Change into this. And get him to come to you." He instructed.

I furrowed my brow. "You want me to... give him head again? But wearing this?" I asked.

Leo chuckled. "No." He said. "I want you to get him to f**k you."

I blinked at him. "I'm sorry what?"

"I want you to get him to f**k you." Leo repeated amused.

"But... Wouldn't all of you want to be there when that happens?" I asked confused.

Both boys gave me a genuine smile making my heart flutter.

"Usually yes, but you've been getting brave lately. You tried to f**k Oliver." Leo said.

"So?"

"So, I changed the rules a bit." Leo said.

"Rules?" I asked.

Leo nodded. "I told everyone to take it slow with you. Ease you into this, with us. I didn't want to freak you out. But since that stunt you pulled with Oliver..." He trailed off. I just blinked at him.

Milo chuckled. "Leo told us that whoever can hold out the longest from you, can be in charge for our first real time together. All five of us."

I looked at Leo. "You made a bet to give over control?" I asked shocked.

Leo smirked. "If they can beat me."

"That's why you guys have barely been touching me all week." I said as I realized it.

Milo nodded. "Oliver has already accepted that he won't win, so he hasn't let up on you."

I frowned. "So, what do I get out of this?" I asked.

Milo laughed.

"You get what you've been wanting from us." Leo stated. "To get f****d better than you ever have before."

I blushed. "And the faster that I seduce all of you, the faster we can all be together?" I asked.

Milo smiled widely. "That's right cupcake."

"And you two are conspiring against Atlas." It wasn't a question, but Milo answered anyways.

"Yes. He'll be the easiest to take down, aside from Oliver." He said.

I thought about what they said. After I sleep with Oliver and Atlas, it would leave the two of them. Something in me started to get excited. I wonder if this will be fun. "Okay. I'll do it."