Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 51

"Good morning cupcake." Milo greeted me when we got downstairs.

"I got you a plate right here angel." Oliver told me as he patted the chair next to him.

I sat down, and thanked Oliver.

"You guys, look what Millie got me for my birthday. I mean.. other than last night." Atlas said, and then gave me a wink.

I blushed.

Atlas handed the album to Milo, and told him to open it up. They all already know what I got Atlas, but none of them had actually seen it yet. Apparently, they all think it's really cool. "How are you feeling this morning angel?" Oliver asked me.

I shurgged. "A little sore." I admitted.

Oliver nodded, but looked slightly sad.

"Not sore enough that she wasn't ready to go bright and early though, right princess?" Leo asked from the other side of the table.

I looked up, and frowned at him.

"What's so wrong with that?" I asked as I crossed my arms.

Oliver chuckled, and put his hand on my bare thigh.

"Nothing at all angel. If I would have been in bed with you still, I would of given in to you." He told me.

"And that's why I made you leave before Millie could wake up." Leo said. "She needs to rest today. That means no one is touching her." He ordered.

I scoffed like a bratty teenager who's mom told her she can't go out with her friends.

"That's not fair." I whined.

"I don't care." Leo stated simply.

"Well I do. I did what you wanted me to do last night." I agured.

Leo looked up at me, and raised a brow. "I'll buy you a cookie later." He said before looking back down at his phone.

My mouth hung open. "Your mood swings give me whiplash. I'm going to need more than a fucking cookie." I said.

Milo and Oliver chuckled. Atlas looks very uncomfortable. Leo didn't even look up at me from his phone.

What a fucking asshole. How can he just change the rules at his every whim? It's completely unfair. Why am I even throwing a fit in the first place? Am I really that much of a slut? I want them, yes, but I do know that I'm very sore. Leo probably has a point. That doesn't mean I have to like it though.

"I don't have mood swings. And what else do you want? We are staying here all day anyways." Leo said.

My face softened. "We are?" I asked.

I never asked what was going to happen the day after Atlas's birthday party. It wasn't that I didn't think of it, because I did. Honestly, I was just too afraid to know. I thought that they would probably take me home to stay there all day. Thinking about that now though, it seems kind of silly.

Regardless of how... intimate we all are, we spend almost all of our free time together. As friends. Even if this was just s*x we are still friends, and it was silly of me to think that they wouldn't want to hang out today.

"We sure are. Milo has a hang over. You are sore from last night. Our parents aren't arriving until late tonight, so, we are staying here today." Leo said.

"Oh. Okay." I said softly.

"Did you think we were just going to take you home as soon as you woke up princess?" Leo asked.

I looked up to see them all staring at me. A blush crept up my neck, and settled in my cheeks. Great, now they're going to make fun of me.

I cleared my throat. "No." I lied.

"Liar." Milo called me out.

"So anyways," I said trying to change the subject. "What are we gonna do today then?" I asked.

"Movie day." Oliver said. "We are each picking one out. You are going to relax, and not lift a finger." He told me.

I smiled. "What am I? Broken now?" I asked with a laugh.

"You said yourself that you're sore." Leo said.

"Yeah, but not so sore I can't do anything. You guys gonna pee for me too?" I teased.

The guys chuckled.

"Since it's our fault you're sore, we want to take care of you." Milo told me.

I turned to him. "You are probably the least likely to blame. I know it was all Leo's plan, and it was Oliver and Atlast that fucked me." I said blatantly.

Milo smirked. "I guess that's true. They give it to you good baby? Was it hard to get Atlas to slip inside that beautiful, tight, wet p***y?"

With every word his voice grew slower and lower. I'm already wet again. I want him so badly. All of them. It's just Milo and Leo left, and then I can have them all. "Stop it the two of you." Leo ordered.

I turned to him, and frowned. "You're being a c**k block Leo." I stated.

The three others sputtered out laughter. Leo raised a brow at me, but I could see the corners of his lips twitch. Hmmm, I wonder if I could get Leo to f**k me before Milo. I would love nothing more than to make him lose this bet. "Just for one day princess, you'll survive." He said.

"Yeah, it's not that bad just hanging out with us is it?" Oliver asked amused.

I sighed heavily. "I guess not." I teased. "So, what did the two of you do last night?" I asked Leo and Milo.

I tried to keep my voice light. After seeing those girls hit on Leo and Oliver last night I wasn't sure what to think. They told me that they only want me, but I still wasn't sure about that. It wasn't that I don't believe them, it's just.. Why would they only want me? Especially while I'm upstairs getting fucked by two of them. Why would the other two just... wait for us?

Milo smirked. "Well, Leo made me sober up, but I was still sneaking alcohol." He told me. "And then some uninvited guests showed up, and that sobered me right up." He said.

"What?" I asked.

Leo sighed, and gave Milo a hard look before turning to me.

"James and Vanessa showed up. With Milinda and Josh. But don't worry princess, we took care of it. They didn't even make it inside." He told me.

I furrowed my brow. "Why would I be worried? I told you that they could come, and that I didn't care." I said.

Leo shrugged. "You might be willing to let things go babe, but we are not."

"Yeah, I would have kicked their asses myself. If I wasn't already busy." Atlas told me with a wink.

I blushed, and then turned my head back to Milo and Leo.

"You guys got into a fight?" I asked.

Leo sighed, and looked up at me. "No princess, it didn't get that far." He said.

I nodded. "Okay. Well, what else did you do last night?" I asked.

Milo chuckled.

"Why do you want to know so bad princess?" Leo asked amused.

I shrugged. "Just curious." I said.

"That so?" Leo asked, and I nodded.

"This wouldn't have anything to do with what you said last night would it? About those girls?" Milo asked.

My face flushed. "Not at all." I lied.

"What girls?" Atlas asked.

"Oh, just these two girls that were trying to get with Leo and me." Oliver said. "Millie saw them flirting with us, and she got all upset."

I scoffed. "Flirting? One of them sat right in Leo's lap." I argued.

Milo chuckled. "Someone got jealous." He said.

I frowned. "I was not jealous. I couldn't care less." I lied.

Leo laughed at that. "No?" I shook my head. "I think you're only saying that because I teased you in front of them. I still remember how wet you were in that moment. You loved that I was showing them that I belong to you." He said. My heated so fast I thought steam would roll off of me.

"Belong to me..?" I mumbled lowly.

Leo offered me a genuine smile. "How many times do I have to tell you Millie? You're ours, and in return, we are yours." He said.

I stared into his green eyes. This was too confusing. What does that even mean? How can they all be mine with only me in return? I'm not even that special. It's not like I'm super hot, or that I was some innocent virgin. I'm just a plain girl. I barely have friends, everyone hates me, I'm nothing special. Not like them.

"Do I really even deserve all of you?"

I didn't realize that I asked that question out loud for a moment. My face flushed, and everyone in the room paused. All eyes fell to me. I looked at my hands in my lap.

Why did I say that?

My god, that was so embarrasing. How are they even supposed to actually answer that? I don't want them to just say things to make me feel better, but I also kind of want to know.

"You don't feel like you deserve us all?" Milo asked softly.

I shook my head, but refused to look up at them.

Someone put their fingers under my chin, and lifted my face up. I met my favorite pair of hazel eyes. Oliver's eyes bore into mine, making me feel lost.

"Why do you feel that way Millie? Are we not making you feel special enough?" He asked me.

I furrowed my brow. "N-No, that's not it." I said.

"Then what is it babygirl?" Atlas asked.

I turned to him. Then I looked at each of the others. Atlas and Milo look worried. Oliver looks sad. Leo is expressionless as always.

"I just.." I trailed off. "I just don't get it I guess. I mean... I'm nothing special. I'm just a regular girl. I didn't even have friends before I met you guys.." I said awkwardly.

"You think you don't deserve us all because other kids at school bully you for absolutely no reason?" Leo asked.

I guess he had a point.

"Well, no, I guess." I said quietly. "I just.. I have all four of you, and I'm just supposed to believe that I deserve all of you in return? And that's supposed to be it for you all? Just me? It just.. doesn't seem fair to me." I admitted.

It's not like I want them all to get someone else. Not even one other someone else. I want them all. It's selfish, and I know that, but I that's what I want. At least for now. Maybe there will come a day that I wouldn't mind another girl join-

Wait.

Why does that even matter? It's not like we are in a relationship. We're just sleeping with each other. Sort of. If they are fucking someone else, then would it really matter how I feel?

"Yes." Leo stated sternly.

I looked up at him. "Yes?" I asked confused.

Leo nodded. "That's right." Was all he said before he got up, and took his plate to the sink.

What?

"Listen cupcake," Milo started. "I know that it's hard to wrap your pretty little head around, but we only want you. I know we have only said it a million times, but you need to get used to it. We are not with anyone else. Never will be. And just you is all that we want. You are more than enough." He told me.

"But.. that isn't fair." I muttered lamely.

"It's fair to us." Atlas said. "We like sharing one girl, and one girl only. And that girl is you baby. Get used to it."

"They're right angel." I turned to look at Oliver. "You might think it's not fair, but that's not how we feel. We want to share you. We like it. We like watching each other with you, and doing things together. Just you. No one else." He said.

I just stared at them all in shock. They.. all want me like that? Just me? Really?

I felt my face heat.

"And for the record," Leo looked me in my eyes. "We think you are very special."