Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 65

Lila, Caleb, and I spent the next several hours hanging out. I actually had tons of fun hanging out with the two of them together. It kept my mind off of things, and I really needed that. All too soon, Mom and Dad came home. It was very late. They offered to let Lila stay the night in my bedroom, but she decided to go home.

I've been laying in my bed for a few hours now. I can't sleep. James knows where I live. He knows how to climb up to my window. I can't calm myself down enough to sleep.

I grabbed my phone to check the time. It's 1:32 a.m. I've been trying to sleep for over an two hours. Will I ever be able to sleep?

I went to my text messages, and my thumb hovered over the group chat with the guys. If one of them came here I bet I would feel safe. Would they really do that for me though? Sighing I typed out a message.

Me: Don't read too much into this, but... are any of you awake?

Replies came in almost instantly.

Atlas: I'm awake babygirl.

Oliver: I'm awake. You alright angel?

Milo: Want me to call you cupcake?

Leo: Are you having trouble sleeping?

My heart warmed. They all replied so fast. I couldn't help the smile that fell on my lips.

Me: I can't sleep.. I... just don't feel safe alone. James knows where I live..

Leo: We can't all come over princess. You can pick two of us.

Me: We've been over this before. I can't just choose. I'll be fine I guess.

I know that it's silly for me to be irritated that they can't all come over. I mean, what was I thinking? That they would all come running, and we could all sleep in my bed? Okay, maybe that is exactly what I was thinking.

Leo: Milo and Oliver will be over soon.

I smiled at my phone.

Me: Maybe you and Atlas tomorrow?

Leo: Only if you don't want any 'space'.

Great now he's teasing me.

Me: I'll take all the space I want, AND you'll still come see me.

Leo: Whatever you want princess.

My heart soared.

*********************

A very short while later there was a tap on my window. Milo and Oliver quietly opened it up, and snuck in. I smiled at them from my bed. "Thank you for coming." I said.

"Anything for you angel." Oliver said as he came to join me on my bed. "You just want us here so you can sleep?" He asked.

"What else would it be?" Milo asked. "She just told us she needs space earlier today."

Oliver turned his bright hazel eyes to me.

"You're just using us?" He asked.

I crossed my arms, and furrowed my brow.

"That's right." I stated.

Oliver smiled. "Good. I'd trade my left nut to have you use me angel."

Oliver kicked off his shoes, and tore off his hoodie. He moved my blankets, and tired to crawl into bed with me. I stopped him right before though.

"You're going to sleep in your jeans?" I asked.

"I didn't think you'd want me to sleep in my underwear." He said.

"Well, why didn't you wear pajama's or something?" I asked.

Oliver blushed.

"We didn't think about it cupcake." Milo told me. "You needed us, and we came running."

I sighed. "Well, I can't just let you guys be uncomfortable then." I mumbled.

Milo smirked at me. "Does that mean you want us to-"

"To be comfortable, yes." I interrupted.

Both of them tried to hide their smirks, but I caught them. Oliver was the first to strip out of his clothes. I tried to keep my eyes off of him as he slid his pants off, and pulled his shirt over his head. I guess I did tell them to be comfortable. Oliver watched me the entire time he undressed. He pulled my blankets back, and crawled into my bed with me. I'm still sitting up, but Oliver laid down like he's about to fall asleep.

I looked up at Milo. He slowly pulled his shirt over his head. I gulped as my eyes raked over his abs. Milo slowly undid his jeans, and pushed them to the floor.

"Ya know, I'm most comfortable sleeping naked." Milo said lowly.

My eyes raked up his body to settle on his deep blues.

"You sleep naked?" I asked.

Milo nodded. "Sure do."

"Well, you don't tonight." I stated.

Milo chuckled. "Worth a shot." He mumbled as he crawled into my bed on the other side of me.

Once the both of them were laying down, I moved to lay too. I rolled onto my side, facing Milo. Oliver wrapped his arm around me, and pulled me tight to his chest. Milo rolled over to face me. He moved in close so that I'm sandwhiched between the two of them. "Thank you for coming." I whispered to the both of them.

Oliver kissed the back of my bare shoulder.

"We would do anything for you angel." He said.

Milo tilted my chin up so that my eyes meet his.

"We would, but.. Please don't ignore us for too much longer okay? We need you." He said.

I nodded. "I'm just not sure what to think about all of this still. And you guys have a lot to make up for." I said.

"All we want is for things to go back how they were. Only we want to tell you that we love you more, hold your hand more, claim you. Ya know, all the relationship stuff." Oliver told me.

"Like dates?" I asked.

Milo chuckled. "You want us to take you out more?" He asked.

I shrugged. "I don't know." I mumbled.

"Millie, would you like to go on a date with the four of us this weekend?" Milo asked.

My cheeks heated. "Uhm.. w-where?" I asked.

Milo shrugged. "I'm sure we can come up with something."

"O-okay." I whispered.

Oliver shot up so that he could look down at me.

"Wait, really?" He asked.

I nodded. "I guess that could be a start."

"No, a start would be having lunch with us tomorrow." Milo said.

I narrowed my eyes at him. "Who are you? Leo junior?"

Oliver snorted. "Don't push her Milo." He said.

"I'll think about it." I said.

"Well, I'll walk you to your locker after our class together, and you can tell me then. I won't pressure you, and if you decide that you don't want to, then maybe you, and the girls can have lunch together." Milo offered. "Okay." I said with a smile.

Oliver settled back behind me. I snuggled between the two of them. This is exactly what I needed.

"Do you guys think I'll ever feel safe again?" I asked softly.

"We will make sure you do cupcake." Milo whispered.

"Ya know, just because I said date does not mean that I'm going to be doing anything with any of you." I said as I drew random patterns on Milo's bare chest. "It's just a simple date. Just me giving you a chance." I said. "Okay angel." Olive said.

"Ya know, you said something like that the first time you kissed me. I think we had just met that day. Or was it the day after? I'm not sure." Milo said.

"She made out with Atlas, you, and me that day." Oliver commented. "Pretty sure I would have made her c*m if that stupid bell didn't ring." He said.

"That's right.. You were so worked up because of Oliver, that-"

I slapped my hand over Milo's mouth.

"Shut up. What are you trying to do? Make me horny?" I asked.

Milo removed my hand from his mouth.

"Why? Is it working?" He asked.

I rolled my eyes. No way in hell am I going to admit that it is working. I still remember that day. No matter how wrong it should have felt to be passed around by them, it didn't. If anything it felt right.

"I'm just teasing you cupcake." Milo said as he pushed himself into me more. "I just missed you a lot is all. Everything felt so meaningless without you Millie."

"None of us were whole." Oliver added.

"You guys are just saying that." I said softly.

"Nope." Milo said.

"Angel, we told you how we feel about you." Oliver said.

I sighed. "You guys are a bunch of freaks." I said.

Both of them chuckled.

"Baby, you have no idea. You haven't even been with me, or Leo yet." Milo said.

"And you haven't been with all of us at once either." Oliver added.

That reminded me of their bet.

"Is that bet still on?" I asked.

Milo froze, and Oliver laughed.

"Oh yeah, angel, it's still on. Why?" Oliver asked.

"Just wondering." I lied.

"Well, you know that I've already lost. Any time that you're feeling like using me more than just to sleep next to.." Oliver trailed off.

I rolled my eyes, and elbowed him in the gut.

"Shut up." I grumbled.

Though, I was going to keep that in mind. I might be mad at them still, but I can't deny how good it feels to have them back. It's been a very short amount of time, but they just make me feel so safe. They've also been here for me as soon as I ask. Things aren't going to just fall back to normal. I need to make them work for it, but I can still be their friend. I can still use them for whatever I want, and whenever I want.

"Do you think you'll be able to get some sleep now?" Oliver whispered.

I shrugged. "I haven't tried yet, but I feel safer now. I can shut my eyes without freaking out." I said softly.

"Have you thought any more about telling the police?" Milo asked.

"Milo." Oliver scolded him.

"It's okay." I said. "Lila talked me into at least speaking to her dad. We are going to see him tomorrow after school." I told them. "That's it though. I'm not making any promises further than that." I stated.

Both of them squeezed their arms around me. I snuggled between the two of them. How can being sandwhiched between two muscley guys be so comfortable?

"Leo will be happy to hear that." Milo mumbled.

"Will he?" I asked.

"Mhmm." Oliver humed out.

"Good. Don't tell him." I ordered.

Milo let out a short hollow laugh.

"Cupcake, we can't-"

"You can." I interrupted. "You all owe me. I don't care how Leo feels, I'm in charge now." I declared.

Oliver chuckled. "You gonna tell Leo that?" He asked.

"I am." I decided.

Milo laughed. "It's funny because he's gonna give in. Especially with how fragile our relationship is right now."

"Friendship." I corrected.

Oliver leaned over to press a kiss to my cheek.

"Relationship." He argued.

I rolled my eyes. "This is just like how it was in beginning. All four of you are back to your boundary issues." I said.

Milo chuckled. "Well, if I'm already pushing boudaries.. Then, I'd like to ask for something." He said.

"And what's that?" I asked.

"Can I have a good night kiss?" He asked softly.

Milo cupped the side of my face, and lifted my head up. Even in the dark I can make out the smirk on his handsome face. My heart started to beat faster the closer he moved to me. "One kiss. That's it. A small peck." I said breathlessly.

Milo is so close to me.

"Okay cupcake." He whispered, and his breath fanned my lips.

I held my breath as Milo pressed his lips to mine.

Pure bliss shot through my body. The moment his lips touched mine all sense left my body. My hands reached up his chest, then further to tangle in his hair. Our lips moved against each other.

My tongue flicked out to trace across Milo's bottom lip. Milo opened his mouth, and I gladly slipped my tongue inside. He tastes so good. I missed his tongue ring.

I pushed my chest into Milo, and my ass back against Oliver. Hands are roaming my body, lighting me on fire. A moan slipped past my lips, but was swallowed up by Milo.

All too soon, Milo pulled away. We're both panting. Oliver still has his hands roaming over my ass.

"Just a quick peck." Milo whispered.

"Shut up." I whispered back.

"Okay, my turn for a good night kiss." Oliver said.

Don't ask me why I rolled over, and pracitcally jumped Oliver. I'm supposed to be angry with all of them. Not letting them touch me while I shove my tongue down their throats. Although, if that's the case, then why do I crave it so much?