Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 69

Lila and I walked out of her fathers office. Out of the building. Into her car.

My mind is blank. I feel like I'm in a dream. Even as I got into my best friends car, and she turned to me.

"You just told me dad that you, and his son are in a polyamorous relationship with all of his best friends children." Lila stated. "Uh huh."

"You just... rushed it all out." She said.

"Uh huh."

"You said you were sleeping with all of them, and then said all their names."

"Uh huh."

"Millie... Are you okay?" Lila asked.

Finally, I lifted my head to look at her.

"Uh huh."

Lila laughed. "Are you? Cause you seem like you're in after shock, or something."

"Uh uh."

Lila laughed again. "Was it just me, or did my dad seem totally unbothered by it?" She asked.

"Uh huh."

"Are you broken?" Lila asked.

I gave her a scared look.

"Uh huh."

Lila blew out a breath. She pulled her phone out, and started tapping away. I looked straight ahead out the windshield.

I can't believe I did that. I had all the time in the world to stop myself, and I didn't. I just admitted to Leo's father, that I've been sleeping with his son. And three other guys. And that we all do things together. And Adam seemed so unbothered by it.

Did he already know? Or suspect? Were we obvious? Did Leo already tell him, and just not tell me?

"Okay, how do you feel about a slumber party at Atlas's place?" Lila asked. "Huh?" I asked.

"That's... sort of progress." Lila said. "His parents are out of town for the night. Jen does these life coach like conference things every month. Henry always goes with her, because he can't bear to be away from her for more than half a day." Lila said with a laugh. "So, we're going there."

"Uh huh."

"Great." Lila mumbled.

What feels like, just a minute later, I'm walking into Atlas's house. Lila lead me to the living room, and sat me on the couch. I'm just staring at the ground still reeling from what just happened.

I have to tell my parents.. Oh, I can just imagine the talk now.. Dad fuming, while Mom looks ready to throw a damn wedding. She has always wanted me to take advantage of my teenage years. Dad is going to be so disappointed in his little girl. "Millie?" Oliver asked.

"Uh huh." I replied without looking.

"Hey babygirl. I'm so happy you made it." Atlas said as he sat next to me, and threw his arm around my shoulders.

"Uh huh."

"Uhmmmm... You okay angel?" Oliver asked.

"Uh huh."

Silence.

"She's broken." Lila confirmed.

"Uh huh."

"See." Lila said.

"Slumber party! I'm stoked." Caleb said. "Oh hey Mil... You okay?"

"Uh huh."

"Uhhhmmm..." Caleb trailed off.

"Don't worry, we'll explain when everyone gets here." Lila said.

A hand cupped my cheek, and turned my face. I stared into the light blue eyes that I love. My body relaxed, and I smiled. Atlas gave me my favorite lopsided smile. Atlas. The guy I just admitted I've been f*****g. That is apparently my boyfriend. One of four.

My smile fell, and I turned my eyes back to the floor.

I admitted this to Leo's dad. I could have just said that we were all dating, but no, I just had to flat out say I'm getting f****d by your son, and all his friends. "Hey, Leo and me are here." Milo called. "Hey, there's my cupcake."

He sat on the other side of me. His cupcake. His. Cause he's one of my four boyfriends.

I think I might be having a mental breakdown.

"You okay Millie?" Milo asked.

"Here it comes." Lila groaned.

"Uh huh." I replied.

"There it was." Caleb commented.

"Princess, what's wrong?" Leo asked.

"Uh huh."

"Okay, what the f**k happened Lila?" Leo asked.

"Uhm, well.. Maybe Millie should tell you." Lila replied. "Mil."

"Uh huh."

Caleb snorted out laughter. I heard several deep sighs in the room. Still, I can't stop spiraling.

What are their parents going to think of me? What if they all hate me? What if this ruins my parents friendships?

Hands grabbed either side of my face. My head was lifted up. I stared into deep green eyes. The same deep green eyes I just admitted things too. "Millie, what is going on? You're starting to freak us out." Leo said softly.

"I.." I trailed off.

"Holy shit, she said a different word." Lila commented making Caleb laugh.

"I did it." I rushed out.

"Oh, she sure did." Lila laughed.

"You did what baby?" Leo asked ignoring his twin.

"I.. I.. Oh my god." I said as I closed my eyes, and groaned.

Lila laughed. "Just spit it out Mil! You had no problem rushing to tell my dad."

My eyes snapped to hers. "That was different!" I said.

Leo forced my eyes back to his, since he's still holding my face.

"What did you tell our dad princess?" He asked softly.

"I.. I told him that I've been sleeping with all of you, and that we're all in a relationship." I rushed out.

Silence.

"Well, I told him you were all in a relaionship, but Millie just offered up the rest all on her own. She even named you all. It was kind of sweet." Lila said. More Silence.

"Damn Millie, I can't believe you admitted it to someone else. You barely admit it to yourself." Caleb laughed.

"Ain't that the truth." Lila snickered.

"Will the two of you give us some privacy?" Oliver asked them.

"Oh, you mean all four of you want a moment alone with your girlfriend?" Lila teased.

"We would, thanks." Oliver replied cheerfully as he pushed up his glasses.

Lila and Caleb left, I could still hear them teasing as they walked away.

I'm still staring into Leo's deep green eyes. He's just staring back at me. The only emotion I can pick up on, is shock.

Leo is the one I was most worried to tell. It was his father I came clean to afterall. Is he going to hate me for outting our relationship?

"Is that true Millie?" Leo asked me. "You told me my dad we're in a relationship?"

I nodded. "Yeah." I breathed out.

Leo just stared at me in complete awe.

"I'm sorry." I whispered. "Are.. you mad?"

"Mad?" Leo asked.

I nodded. "I just outted you to your dad."

"No baby," Leo chuckled. "You just offically confirmed to be with us, that's all." He said.

"Huh?" I asked confused.

"I knew you didn't need space." Atlas said as he wrapped his arms around my waist.

Leo let go of my face, and stood up. Milo gripped my chin, and turned my face to him. He smirked at me.

"I should have known by that kiss last night that you already knew you belong to us." He said.

"Yeah, we just didn't expect you to admit it so soon." Oliver commented amused.

I looked around at all of them.

"I'm so confused. You aren't... mad? I mean, Adam said he wouldn't tell anyone, but if I go through with this case, all of our parents are probably going to find out. He told me to tell my parents before they found out in court." I said.

Leo chuckled lowly. "Silly little princess." He said. "My dad already knows the lifestyle I want. I've never kept it a secret from anyone." He told me.

"Huh?" I asked confused.

"Babygirl, all of our parents are aware. We told them when we were with Holly. They might think it's a phase, and they might not have known we are with you, but.." Atlas trailed off.

"Mine know." Oliver said.

I snapped my head to him. "What?"

"Mine too." Milo said.

My eyes snapped between the two of them.

"I'm still having a break down aren't I?" I asked.

Oliver chuckled. "No angel. Look, we came clean to our parents a while ago. They were.. mad, and confused at first. But I think they trust us to make our own decisions for the most part. The only things new that you told Adam, is that you're our girlfriend now." He said. "My parents already knew something was going on. I never kept my interest in you a secret."

"Me neither." Milo said. "Mom kept trying to get me to take you flowers, and chocolate for the last couple weeks during our fight." He admitted. "She's probably the most supportive out of all our parents."

I stared at them all with my jaw on the floor.

"I thought.. I thought that we were all a secret.." I said.

"We only kept things low key for you princess." Leo said. "We never cared who saw, or what anyone has to say." Then Leo got down to my level. "You do understand what this means, right baby?"

I gulped. "That I have to tell my parents?" I asked.

Leo chuckled. "Not until you're ready, no."

"Then what does it mean?" I asked.

"That we're all offically together now." Oliver said. "You admitted that you're our girl. Now it's offical."

"That doesn't really make it offical." I mumbled.

"No?" Leo asked, and I shook my head. "What would make it offical then?" He asked.

I swollowed. "Uh, well, uhm, I don't know."

"We told you what we wanted Millie." Milo said. "We waited for your answer."

"And apparently you gave it to Leo's dad first." Atlas chuckled.

"That doesn't-"

"Oh, yes it does princess." Leo interrupted. "You're ours now. No take backsies."

I scrunched up my face. "Did you just say, no take backsies?"

"He sure did." Oliver laughed.

"Look what you did cupcake, got Leo all worked up, tripping over his words, and saying silly things." Milo whispered in my ear.

I looked into Leo's eyes.

"Does this mean the bet's off?" I asked.

Leo smirked. "Not a chance." He said. "Now, tell us what my dad said? What do we have to do now?" He asked.

I crossed my arms. "Well, for starters you could have told me that James pressed charges against you." I said.

Leo sighed. "It was no big deal, my dad ha-"

"Handled it I know. He said the same thing." I interrupted with an eyeroll.

"Interrupting me, and rolling your eyes. That's two princess." Leo commented.

I blushed.

"Well, according to Millie, she's in charge now, so you better watch yourself Leo." Milo said amused.

"Really? And when did she say that?" Leo asked.

"Last night." Oliver answered.

"So much for secrets." I muttered. "I am in charge though. So, you can take your little punishments, and shove them up your a*s." I stated.

Leo raised a brow at me. "That's three."

I felt my core tighten. Damn it. Leo, and his stupid punishments.

"Now, what'd he say?" Leo asked again.

"He told me to think about what to do next. He said that the case could go either way really, since there are no witnesses other than you." I told Leo. "But he said that I should come clean to my parents. Then I'd have to file a police report." I told them. "What do you think you're going to do?" Oliver asked me.

"She's going to file that police report." Leo answered.

I sighed. "I have to talk to my parents first." I said. "They're going to freak out." I said.

"It's okay babygirl, we will be with you through the whole thing. No matter what you chose." Atlas said.

"There was something else your dad said. I've been worrying this whole time about James possibly doing this to someone else in the future, but.. Do you guys think that he's already done it before? What if there are other girls at school that we don't know about?" I asked.

"I didn't think about that." Milo murmured.

"We will figure it out Millie. If there are... you taking this step could be the step they need." Leo told me.

I nodded. "You're right." I said.

Just then the doorbell rang. Milo jumped up from the couch. He rubbed his hands together, and looked down at me.

"Oh, on a brighter note.. I ordered chinese."