Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 76

Oliver's P.O.V.

*************************

My poor little angel looked terrified when her dad asked to speak with us. I almost feel bad for being so amused. Millie is just so cute with her big eye scared eyes, and those juicy parted lips.

Hard to believe I had those lips wrapped around my d**k just yesterday. We were in the janitors closet. Millie pulled me in, and pracitcally jumped me. I'm absolutely loving this s*x crazed side of our girl. "Dad, please-" Millie started, but Leo interrupted her.

"It's alright Millie." Leo said as he stood up.

Leo looked at all of us expectantly. We all followed suit. Milo is relaxed as always. Leo is keeping his cool, but I just hope he doesn't say some dumb alpha male shit. Atlas looks petrified. I'm in between.

I don't want to disrespect David at all, but I will not stay away from his daughter. I'm not really sure what this talk is going to entail though. Will David ask us to stay away from his daughter? Or, is he just going to threaten us, like any other father? We followed David into the house. I caught my moms eye, and she gave me a thumbs up. Darla looks smug as she sips on her whine. Betty and Sarah are talking in hushed tones. All of our dads refuse to meet our eyes.

David lead us to the living room. He gesutred for us to sit. Leo and I took the couch, while Atlas and Milo each took a chair. Then David began to pace in front of us.

"I don't agree with this." David finally announced.

Leo blew out an annoyed breath. He opened his mouth, probably to say something stupid, but I put my hand on his arm.

"We understand that Mr. Holmebrooke, but we love your daughter." I said.

David's eyes snapped to mine.

"How can you all love her? All... be together at the same time?" He asked.

"We just do." Atlas said.

"It doesn't bother us to all be with her. We've known each other our whole lives. We know that each of us would treat her right, be loyal to her and each other, and love Millie uncondionally." Milo said. Couldn't of said it better myself.

"So, you all just pass my daughter around then, is that it?" David asked angrily.

"No. It's not like that." Atlas defended. "We all spend time together."

"Mr. Holmebrooke, we aren't all just dating your daughter." Leo said. "We are all together. All of us in one relationship."

David shook his head. "I don't understand this type of relationship." He muttered.

"That's alright. You don't have to. It's about Millie, and how she feels." Leo said.

Shit. Leo has a point, but he could have said it better. David looks pissed.

"What Leo means, is that like any other relationship, all that matters is that Millie is happy, and healthy. We love her, all of us, a lot." I said.

"And what if someone else comes along? Do you just keep adding people? Is my daughter going to come home one day crying because you all invited another girl into this?" David shot question after question. "Trust me, none of us want anyone else." Milo said.

"These are also fears Millie had. We've already talked about this with her. She knows that we only want to be with her." Atlas said.

David sighed, and ran a hand down his face.

"Mr. Holmebrooke, can I ask you something?" I asked.

David nodded.

"Millie, she was very sad when we first moved here. Haven't you noticed how happy she's been since hanging out with us?" I asked. David's eyes softened.

"We make her happy. We love, and cherrish her in every way we can." Leo added.

"And believe us, she doesn't always make it easy." Milo muttered.

"Millie gives us shit all the time if that is what your worried about." Leo said. "Your daughter has a strong spirit. She isn't one to get bossed around easily. She's a fighter. She gives us shit, and makes us work for any ounce of attention she gives us. Trust us sir, Millie is not being used, or talked into anything." Leo said.

David chuckled. "Her mother said the same thing." He muttered.

I smiled. "I am sorry that this is so hard for you to wrap your head around sir, but we love your daughter, and she loves us." I said.

"We can't stay away from her if that's what you want to ask." Atlas rushed out.

David chuckled again. "You are just like your father."

Atlas offered a small smile.

"Your parents have talked with me a bit about this. I see I am not the only one who is uncomfortable with this. I have questions." David said.

"Ask away." Milo said.

"How exactly is this going to work after you all graduate? Millie is going to college." He stated.

I nodded. "Millie and I have talked about the schools she wants to go do. She wants to stay close to home. Ironically, the school she chose is also the one that I will be attending. Leo will be attending their law program, but it is held in a different building than where Millie and I would be. Atlas isn't sure what he wants to do. And Milo will be going to a school on the other side of the city." I finished.

"You already talked about this with Millie?" David asked.

I shook my head. "We just talked college, not about going together. I didn't even tell her that Leo would be going there too, just me."

"And how do you all plan to make this work? Millie will most likely be staying in the dorms." David asked.

"Unless we all get an apartment somewhere in the city that works well for all of us." Leo said.

David's eyes narrowed at him. "You want to move in with my daughter?"

"Yes." Leo said with no hesitiation.

David sighed. "And how does Millie feel about this?" He asked.

Leo shrugged. "We haven't asked her yet."

I'm glad he said 'asked' and not 'told'.

"She's probably going to say no at first, hopefully she comes around though." Milo said. "Because we desperately love her, and do not want to lose her."

David looked at all of us before sighing again.

"What about if Millie gets pregnant? Then what? It could be any of yours, what would you do?" David asked.

Leo shifted uncomfortably. Kids is not his favorite subject. Milo also looks uncomfortable. Same with him. Neither of them have thought much about kids. Which is ironic considering how much we all c*m in Millie.

"If Millie gets pregnant we will handle it." Atlas said.

I smiled. This is Atlas's best subject. He's already went on and on about how all of our kids will look like Millie, and be the best little things to walk the earth.

"We hope that doesn't happen any time soon, but if it does, then we will figure it out together. As for who's it would be.. Well, any baby that comes out of Millie, would be just as much mine, as theirs. If Millie wants to know which one of is the biological dad, then she can, but I don't care either way. I'll love that child just as much as I love their mother."

My heart could explode with how cute that was. Atlas is the sweetest one out of all of us. He has a heart of gold, and he isn't afraid to show it to everyone.

I agree with everything he said, just like I know the rest of us do. I'm not sure how Millie would feel if she actually got pregnant, but we would figure it out. Together.

"I don't think you understand how hard a decision like that would be." David said.

Atlas shrugged. "I know that as long as we stick together, we can get through anything. We just have to have good communication." He said.

I beamed at him. Pride swelled in my chest. Atlas is saying all the right things, and he means them with all his heart.

David sighed. "Fine. I can't control Millie. She's an adult, and I don't want to ruin my relationship with my daughter. I don't want to hear more about any of this. It's going to take me a while to come to terms. Until then, you all better make sure my daughter is nothing but happy. She better never come home crying, or heart broken." David warned.

"Got it." I said with a bright smile.

David looked at all of us again. He shook his head, and began mumbling under his breath as he walked back outside.

Atlas blew out a loud breath, and clutched his chest.

"Holy shit. I thought he was going to murder us." He said.

Milo slapped a hand on Atlas's back.

"Glad he didn't." Milo said.

"That actually went better than I expected it to." Leo said.

"Yeah, thanks to Atlas." I said.

Atlas smiled brightly.

"Just don't tell Millie what I said about kids. I don't want to freak her out." He said.

"As long as you don't tell her about the college thing." I said.

"And no one tells her about the apartment. I haven't found one I like yet." Leo said.

Milo let out a loud short laugh.

"Haven't we already learned our lesson about keeping things from Millie?" He asked.

"This is different. She'll totally freak." Leo said.

"Yeah, she'll think I'm a stalker." I said.

"And that I'm obsessed with her." Atlas added.

We all looked at him.

"You are obsessed with her." I said.

"And Millie already knows that." Leo said.

Atlas blushed. "She does?" He asked.

Milo laughed. "Atlas, darling, everyone with eyes knows."

"As long as my babygirl doesn't hate me I guess." Atlas said with a dreamy look in his eyes.

"Is this going to make sneaking into her room harder?" Milo asked.

Leo shook his head. "I don't think so. It seems that David wants to pretend like it isn't happening. As long as we are quiet it should be fine." He said.

"Good." Milo breathed out. "Not sure I could live without giving her late night head every other night." He said.

I laughed. "I agree. I would not survive if it got even harder to get between Millie's legs." I said.

"Luckily, she bends well the backseat of a car." Atlas told us.

"What about our lake house trip? I know we already told her we love her, but I thought we were still taking the trip." I asked.

"We are." Leo answered.

"How? Her parents aren't just going to let her, and Caleb come now." Milo said.

"They will." Leo said confidently.

"What makes you so sure?" Milo asked.

Leo shrugged. "Just a feeling. Don't worry. I'll handle everything. You guys just be ready to go when the time comes. We are still taking that trip, and we are going to have our girl everywhere around that house." He said. I smirked. "We're gonna be up there for a whole week right?" I asked.

"Week and a half. Ten days. I already figured things out with school." Leo said. "We'll be only missing two days, and they are both senior days. So, no other seniors will be at school, and you know Millie doesn't want to do any of the shit they have planned anyways." He said.

"Good. That means, I can get her all to myself for a little while?" I asked.

Leo nodded. "I don't see why not, though she really wants all of us together."

"Yeah, yeah, I know." I said. "I just have a little something planned. I've always wanted to pin her hands to that glass wall, and just give it to her with those perfect boobs pushed into it. While all of you are outside watching us." I shivered.

"I'm getting her in the hot tub." Atlas announced.

"I wonder if I could get her out on the boat.." Milo trailed off as his thoughts consumed him.

"Well, no matter what, we all are getting her together, and I am in charge." Leo said.

I shook my head, and stood up.

"Come on, let's go take our girl some more food to calm her nerves."