Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 33

Leo's P.O.V.

Millie is downstairs with everyone else. I'm still upstairs watching as our mothers all get drunk. I have been spending the last hour or so helping them to get more drunk. It was all part of my plan. Soon our mothers would be too drunk, and then our dads will want to get them home, and that's when we will offer to stay and clean up like the good children we are.

Am I doing this all so that we can have Millie all alone tonight?

Yes.

Do I understand that that also means I'm leaving my sister alone with her boyfriend?

Also yes.

Lila can handle herself and this was all going to be worth it.

Millie's mother just knocked over a glass of wine and the rest of the women giggled hysterically. It's time. I went downstairs to see Atlas and Oliver having a quiet conversation, Lila and Caleb are cuddled up on one side of the couch, and my princess is with Milo at another side. "Guys come here." I called out.

All of them, even Caleb came over. We made a circle and they looked at me expectantly. All the guys have been in on this since yesterday. Little did Millie and Lila know that we took Caleb into out group. He's a really cool guy to start with, but he had noticed the extra attention we had all been giving his sister. We had to come clean to him about our intentions with her. Caleb wasn't happy about it and I still don't think he is, but I think he understands a little bit more after letting us explain. Lila was also a big help with that. “So? They letting us stay?" Caleb asked.

"I haven't asked yet. Our moms are all very drunk. I was thinking we all go up there and ask." I said.

The rest of the guys nodded and Milo turned to the girls.

"We will be right back." He told them before we all went back upstairs.

When we got upstairs our dads are now sitting with our mothers. Some of them look a little too comfortable. My dad looked at me.

"I think it's time for us all to go. The women are all drunk." He said with a laugh.

"Acutally," I started. "We were kind of wondering if you guys would let us kids stay the night here." I offered.

My dad's eyebrows shot up.

"We can clean everything up for you guys and you can have a night to yourselves." Caleb added.

"You want us to leave you here alone with your girlfriend?" His father asked incredulously.

Caleb and I had a plan for that already.

"Yeah cause her twin is going to let anything happen." Caleb said with a laugh. "And Millie is here, the girls can share a room. Us guys will probably play video games all night." He added.

All of our dads seemed to inspect us for a moment. Atlas's dad, Henry was the first to speak.

"Hey, they're all either 18 or almost 18. I think we can trust them. Plus, free clean up." He said.

My dad sighed. "I'll only say yes if David says yes." He said and then looked at his friend.

David looked between us all before sighing himself.

"Fine. But be home at a decent time tomorrow." He said sounding defeated.

"Be safe son." Was all Derek said to Milo.

"Will do Dad." Milo replied with a smile.

A little while later and our parents were gone.

"Should we clean up now or save it for morning?" Oliver asked me.

"I say we do most of it now that way it's done." I said.

The others nodded and we got to work. After about an hour we were pretty much done. The guys sat at the table and Milo and I took them all a beer. We decided to sit and chat about what to do tonight before going down to suprise the girls. "I'm gonna go check on them." Atlas said before walking off.

"Should we all just get really drunk? I know there's some liquor around here somewhere." Milo offered.

"Lila doesn't like drinking that much." Caleb said. I raised a brow at him. "What? I like her so I listen to her." He said making the rest of us laugh.

"Just remember, we will all kick your ass if you hurt her. Even Oliver." Milo said making Oliver roll his eyes.

Caleb chuckled. "I know, I know. Same if you guys hurt my sister." He said.

"We would never hurt Millie." Oliver stated.

Caleb gave him a nod. "I think I believe you all. It's just... weird." He said. "All of you guys together? I mean, isn't that hard? To share..?" He asked uncomfortably.

I shrugged. "That's what we're into." I said simply.

"I get that it's hard to wrap your head around, but we like sharing." Oliver said.

"Millie just can't be with anyone besides the four of us." Milo added.

"So, you guys get jealous of other guys but not each other?" Caleb asked.

I nodded. "That's right."

"How?" Caleb asked.

Ever since he found out that we all wanted Millie he had asked questions like this. It wasn't annoying to me or to Oliver, but I could tell that it bothered Milo and Atlas. After what happened to us before I could understand. This lifestyle isn't for everyone, people don't understand, but that's okay. The only one that matters, is Millie.

"Because we know that none of us will hurt her." Oliver stated.

"Why is Atlas taking so long?" Milo asked. "I'm going to go check on him." He said and then walked off.

"So, tonight you guys are gonna tell my sister about this..... relationship you guys want?" Caleb asked.

I sighed. "Are you sure you really want these details Caleb?" I asked. "I don't ask you about you and my sister."

Caleb shrugged. "Millie has been through a lot. I know that Lila has too but.. this is different. Lila has you four to beat me up if I fuck up. Millie has me and no one else. You don't get how crazy last year was for her. She just started to act like herself again, I don't want her to get hurt." He said.

"We get it Caleb. We won't hurt Millie. I promise." Oliver said.

Just then Lila came walking into the room. She sat down on Caleb's lap and started whispering in his ear. I cringed.

"Get a room." I grumbled out.

"What a great idea. Thanks Leo." She said as she stood and grabbed Caleb's hand.

Lila lead him away and I tried not to think about it. Oliver and I were left sitting and wondering where they hell our others were. Just then Atlas came barreling into the room.

"Uh, we have a... problem I guess." He said.

"A problem?" I asked.

"Is Millie okay?" Oliver asked.

I'll kill everyone in this house if she isn't.

"Oh yeah. Millie is f*****g great." Atlas said.

Oliver left to probably go check on our girl. Atlas walked to the table and snatched his beer before chugging it all. I raised a brow at him waiting for him to explain.

"Well?" I asked impatiently.

"Millie found the brownies..." He said.

"What?" I asked angrily.

"She ate two."

"Fuck." I muttered. "Okay, let's clean this table off and go down there." I said. "She better be okay."

"Oh, she's more than okay." Atlas said with a smirk.

By the time that Atlas and I got downstairs our girl was already being taken care of. Walking in on her sitting on top of Milo, while he has his fingers between her legs, along with Oliver behind her pinching her nipples, and nothing on but a bright red bra and her white thigh highs.... My c**k was instantly hard. I was furious that they touched each other without my say. Millie might be new but the others know the rules.

I forced the guys to come and have a conversation with me in the corner of the room.

"Don't be too mad Leo." Milo said. "How were we supposed to resist that? She literally attacked us." He said and Atlas nodded.

"Not me." Oliver stated making me glare at him.

"What do you guys propose we do? Take turns tonight? She isn't ready for all of us at once." I said.

"You sure about that? She seems really ready right now." Milo argued.

"I don't want to push her and scare her off." I said and then noticed that Oliver was gone. "Oliver." I called and he came up behind me. "What do you think? Should we take turns with her, or should two of us leave?" I asked. "Oh, I definitely think she can handle all of us." He said as he walked around me.

I looked him up and down. "Why the fuck are you naked?" I asked and then I turned around to the most glorious sight.

Fuck. Millie is going to be the death of me. They've all been fooling around behind my back as I compemplate whether Millie was even ready for this or not. One thing is for sure, Millie is defintitely our girl.

Forcing my prinecess to take Milo's cock was hot. And Oliver giving me a taste of her had me ready to explode. It was like the more that we did to her, the more she wanted.

When it came to her spankings, I could tell that she and Milo were excited. This is Milo's favorite part. He loves being punished. I even punished him by making him give me head once. It was interesting for the both of us.

Millie never used her safe word so I thought that it was okay to keep going and get harder. Little did I know she was just trying to put on a brave face for me. Millie thought that being a good girl meant taking everything I gave her. While I was unbelievably proud of her, I didn't want to push her too far. It wasn't that I was that angry with her, it was just hot. I was beyond turned on. Watching as Milo holds onto her while I paddle her a*s red. It was doing all sorts of things to me.

I felt terrible that Millie thought she was too bad of a girl to cum. That wasn't my intention at all. So, I gave her exactly what she wanted. While I fucked her face, the rest of the guys gave her seven orgasms. My eyes would trail across her entire body. I'm a bit shocked by how well she took all of this. It wasn't like we were f*****g her but still.

When we were done I had to force her to drink some water. Millie is so tired that she could barely keep her eyes open. I got up to get Oliver's phone as they all piled into bed with our girl. Then I started to dress.

Millie wanted me to stay and I told her I would be right back. It wasn't a total lie, I'd be back eventually, and I would be crawling right into bed with her. Apparently, if I wasn't here when she woke up, I was getting a spanking anyways. Right now I just have something to do. So, I left our girl in the care of the others and went upstairs.

Over the last week I had been getting texts and calls from the last person I wanted to hear from. The others hadn't heard from her because she knows that I'm in charge. I thought that if I just ignored her that she would stop, but she won't.

I walked upstairs and outside to the back porch. Pulling my phone out I can see that she tried to call me five times while we were with Millie. Anger crashed through me. My phone rang again and it was the same stupid bitch. Sighing, I decided to answer. "Hello Holly."