Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 34

Leo's P.O.V.

"Hello Holly." I said in a bored tone.

"Awh, you don't sound too happy baby, what's wrong?" She asked.

"Don't call me that." I gritted out. "What do you want?" I asked impatiently.

"I just miss you that's all." She said sweetly.

"Well I don't miss you. I thought that ignoring you would get the message across, but I see it has no effect." I said annoyed.

"Don't be like that Leo. I miss you. I miss all of you." Holly's voice sounded sweet and it tugged at my heart strings.

I sighed. "You should have thought about that before. Things are over between us now Holly." I stated.

"Hmmmm, I miss the way you say my name." She said seductively. "Are the others with you? It's pretty late. I've been calling you for hours Leo." She said.

"I was busy." I bit out.

"I thought you were never too busy for me Leo." She said sweetly.

"Why don't you just tell me what the f**k it is you want Holly?" I asked.

Holly sighed. "I mean it Leo." She said honestly. "I miss you, all of you. I should have never let you go. I need you all. I'm so sorry about what I did, but I want to make up for it." She said.

Those were the same words that all of us had wanted to hear from Holly for a few months now. For her to apologize and tell us all that she wants us. But it's too late for that. Holly made choices and this is where we ended up. Not to mention Millie. She has our hearts now. I had zero doubts that the others feel the same. Holly had done too much damage to us.

"You realize we moved states away right?" I asked.

It feels sort of like I'm entertaining this. Why does it feel that way? Would I really do that? No, there's no way. Even if a small part of my heart still hurts over Holly, I could never leave Millie, not for Holly or anyone else.

"I know. I heard that you guys moved to Cali. I was thinking of maybe coming out that way." Holly said.

"What?" I asked incredulously.

"Well, I'm 18 now. You know that Daddy has enough money to send me anywhere. I could get my own apartment, come there, be with you guys." She suggested.

I didn't answer for a moment. I was too stunned. She wants to come out here? For us? What would the guys think about this?

"I don't think that's a good idea Holly." Was all I said.

"Why not? Don't you guys miss me?" She asked but I didn't say anything. If any of us missed her, it doesn't change what she did. "Don't tell me that you guys found someone else to fill my place?" Holly asked with a laugh.

I gripped my phone tighter. Fill her place? That place never belonged to her. We were just too eager and stupid to see it right away. That place has always belonged to Millie. I'm 100% positive about that.

"Fill your place?" I asked disgustedly and then scoffed. "That place was never yours to begin with." I stated. "And yes, we did meet someone else. She is who we want now. So stop calling me, do not bother the others, and leave us all alone." I said. "And if I don't?" She asked. "Will you punish me Leo? I've always enjoyed your punishments." She said.

"If you don't, you won't like this one." I said dangerously. "I mean it Holly. Leave us be. You've done enough." I said and then hung up.

I sighed and ran a hand through my hair. Then the door to the house opened. I looked up to see Oliver in nothing but a pair of boxers. He walked out and took a seat next to me.

"What's going on?" He asked.

Oliver was the most observant out of all of us. He always knows when something is even slightly off. It's the same way with Millie. That's part of how I know she's the one. Oliver could never do that with Holly. Mostly because Holly is really good at manipulation. I sighed. "You can't tell the others." I ordered.

Oliver furrowed his brow. "Okay." He said.

"I just got off the phone with Holly." I said.

Oliver's eyes went wide. For a moment he didn't say anything. I watched several emotions pass over his face.

"Uhhhhmmmm.... What?" He finally asked.

"She's been calling and texting me all week. I have been ignoring her. She called me like 12 times while we were with Millie tonight. I finally answered when she called again." I admitted.

Oliver stared at me with his jaw on the floor. "What did she say? What does she want?" He asked.

I sighed and looked out at the ocean. "Us." I said. "She wants us back."

Oliver scoffed. "And you told her to kindly fuck off right?" He asked. I didn't say anything. "Right?" Oliver asked again.

"I told her that we didn't want her back. That we moved away and moved on. To leave us alone and I hung up." I said.

"Then why are you acting so weird over it? F**k that stupid slut." Oliver said. Again, I didn't say anything. "You aren't seriously thinking about taking her back are you?" Oliver asked incredulously. I shook my head. "No, it's just... She was our first Oli."

Oliver interrupted me before I could finish. "So? Millie is our last. She's perfect for us. She actually cares about us to start off with." He argued.

"Holly cared." I said.

Oliver scoffed. "Yeah, sure she did." Then he stood up. "The others aren't going to want her back. We aren't going to give up Millie for her." He said.

"I already told you that I don't want her back. It's just hard. She was important to us at one point." I said.

"Yeah, and then she tore all of our hearts in half and laughed about it. She's the reason why we agreed to move away." Oliver is nearly shouting at this point.

"Quiet down." I ordered. "The others don't need to know about this." I said.

Oliver ran a hand through his curly hair and sat back down beside me. "Leo, you can't really think that Holly is better than Millie. Please tell me that it's just the hurt getting to you." He begged softly.

I turned to look at him. "I would never give Millie up. I know that I don't want Holly anymore. You jumped to conclusions." I said. "I told Holly we don't want her and I'm going to block her number. It's just dragging up a lot of memories." I admitted.

Oliver slapped his hand on my shoulder. "I think that maybe you should come to bed. Cuddle our girl. Remind yourself how much better we have now." He said.

I smiled at the thought of climbing in bed with Millie. "I don't need a reminder. She's all I think about anyways." I said.

Oliver nodded. "I'm in love with her." He stated confidently.

I raised a brow at him. "Really?" I asked.

Oliver nodded. "She's perfect. She's it. Our missing piece. We all feel the same." He said.

I nodded. Oliver is right. I've noticed it in the others too. It's only been a short time but already Millie has worked her way into our hearts. Of course it started because we all wanted her, we were drawn to her. Something about her called out to us. Which makes me feel even more validated in our feelings for her.

"Yeah, I guess we do." I said.

"Should we tell her?" Oliver asked.

I gave him a wide eyed look. "That we are all in love with her?" I asked and Oliver nodded. "I'm not sure about that. She's still struggling to wrap her head around all of us wanting to f**k her." I said.

Oliver smiled brightly. "She seemed like she was warming up to it." He said.

I smirked. "I guess you're right about that." I said. "Spring break is right around the corner. What do you say that we play our cards right in the meantime and convince our parents to let us vacation at the lake house?" I asked. "Lila and Caleb will have to come but just think about it. All of us with Millie, alone in the woods, a lake and a pool, and all sorts of fun things to do." I said.

"We can take her out on the boat to that one spot and tell her how much we love her. Tell her that we want her to be ours." Oliver suggested.

"Exactly." I said.

Oliver smiled. "Millie would love that." He said.

I smiled as I imagined what her face will look like. Millie is turning me into a softy. Not that anyone else will ever know that.

"What about the other stuff?" Oliver asked more seriously.

"I got the information on Milinda, Vanessa, and James." I said. "You just keep trying to tap into their soical media accounts. So far I have found quite a bit of stuff out about their parents, but that doesn't help us." I said.

Oliver and I have been doing anything we can to dig up dirt on those three. After some investigating we found out that they were the main ones to torment our girl. The messages on Millie's locker had been getting worse. Not that our girl knows that. Atlas had quite the chat with the principal and janitor. It's always cleaned up before Millie finds it.

After a few days of that, we started to notice Milinda and even Vanessa hanging around waiting for Millie to be alone. The moment we noticed we made sure to never leave our girl without protection. This is something that we also brought Caleb in on. Especially when Atlas overheard James talking about our girl.

Getting information about them personally was easy because of James's big ass mouth. But we needed hard proof, not just locker room talk. Although, Atlas's patience is running thin. James thinks that Atlas can't hear the shit he says but Atlas can. James is f*****g around with almost all the cheerleads. Ever since we had been giving Millie more attention though... Well, James has been talking more and more about wanting to get back in her pants.

No way in hell are we going to let anyone lay a finger on our girl. So, I came up with this plan. It's simple blackmail but if it works, it works.

"I cracked through Vanessa's. I found some surprising things." Oliver said.

"Like what?" I asked.

"Well, the only usefull thing we have for blackmail is a video of her giving James head. Poor guy has a small d**k, it's no wonder Millie always gets wide eyed when she sees us." He said with a smirk. "The interesting things I found were tons of pictures of her and Millie growing up. It's all in private albums or drafts but it's there. They used to be friends, good friends." He told me.

"Hmmm." I hummed out.

"What do you think happened?" Oliver asked.

"Probably James and his big mouth." I said.

Oliver nodded. "I wish that we could have been here last year." He said as he looked out at the ocean. "Millie could have been our first and last."

"I think it's a good thing Millie wasn't our first." I said as I recalled how our first relationship went. "We weren't the best then either."

Oliver shrugged. "I think we could have been, for her. Even then." He said.

I nodded. "I think maybe you're right." I said and then stood up. "Alright. Let's go cuddle with our girl." I said and then walked back into the house.

Oliver followed me down to the bedroom where we left the others. Millie is practically laying on top of Altas with Milo snuggling her side. Oliver climbed in beside Atlas and threw his arm over both of them. I stripped down to nothing and climbed under the covers. I was going to wedge myself between Milo and Millie, when she rolled over onto her back. Milo put his head on her chest and Atlas rolled onto his side to wrap an arm around her. I crawled under the covers and rested myself between Millie's legs with my head on her stomach. Oliver was right, this feels right, it feels perfect, and I would be lying it I didn't admit that I am also in love with Millie.