Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 94

"Okay, here is the last bits of stuff. Do you need any help setting the rest up?" Lila asked.

It's Friday evening. Mom helped me convince Dad to let us all stay here. I think that dinner went very well. That, and I think all of our parents understand we are all 18 now, so what does it matter. Well, almost all of us.

Lila and Leo will be 18 next week though.

"No, I think I have it all set up. I just need the guys here." I said.

"Okay. So, I will send them in here, out to the beach in..." Lila trailed off.

"Give me like 20 minutes." I said.

Lila nodded, and handed me the bags of food, and small box of Leo's favorite snacks. I grabbed them, and headed out the back door. Then I paused, and turned around.

"Wait!" I called out.

Lila turned to face me.

"Do I look okay?" I asked.

Lila paused to look me up and down. I'm wearing a simple baby blue bikini. I know already that it's Milo's favorite. I also have a sheer matching cover around my waist. My hair is down, and natural, and no makeup. "You look beautiful as always." Lila finally replied.

I gave her a bored look.

"You were starting to make me panic." I scolded.

Lila laughed. "Sorry, I couldn't help it. Of course you look great. You always do, anddddd they will think so regardless. Those boys are all whipped for you girl." She said.

I blew out a breath. "I guess you're right." I said.

"Okay, go." Lila pushed me in the opposite direction.

I rushed out the back door of the house. The sun is still up, thankfully. I walked to the blanket I have set up. I have a bucket with wine chilling in it. Thanks to Lila. She really came through for me.

I sat up the food, and snacks. Everything looks pretty perfect. I have Milo's surfboard tucked in the sand standing up next to me. And I have Atlas's guitar laid out on the blanket as well.

Everything looks perfect.

I sat on the blanket, and tried to appear relaxed. Pretty sure I look like I'm trying too hard though. I watched the back door of the beach house, and waited.

Maybe 20 minutes was too long. I should have told Lila 10. Maybe I should text her to tell her I'm ready now, before I lose my confidence, and call this whole thing off.

Just as I reached for my phone, I saw them. All four of my boyfriends walked out onto the back porch together. Atlas, and Milo beamed at me. Their faces hold so much excitement. Oliver is just staring at me, I don't really know what to make of his expression. Leo though, Leo looks guilty. As he should.

Atals, and Milo were the first ones to make their way too me. I watched as Oliver walked behind them. The closer they get the more I can see the awe in Oliver's face. I hope that's a good thing.

"Hi." I said softly once they reached me.

"Babygirl, what is all this?" Atlas asked.

I sat up on my knees, and chewed on my bottom lip.

"Well, you guys have been so great to me. Since day one. I know that I didn't make it easy on any of you. I know we have been through a lot. I could never thank you guys enough for everything you are doing for me when it comes to James.." I said softly. "You don't have to thank us for that cupcake." Milo said.

"I know." I said. "But, I wanted to do something for you guys. Something to show you that I appreciate you all. To show you how in love with all of you I am." I said.

"So, I brought Atlas's guitar, so that he can sing to us. I brought Milo's surfboard, so that we can play in the water-"

"And you wore my favorite bikini." Milo interrupted me to say.

I rolled my eyes at him.

"Anyways, I ordered food from Oliver's favorite resturaunt. And Lila helped me get these weird candy's and chips that Leo likes. Oh, and there is wine." I told them all.

I looked up to see them all staring down at me. My cheeks heated. Oh no, was this not okay? Not the right thing to do?

"Uhm, I-I maybe went all out." I said as I forced out a laugh. "I, uhm, we, uhm, can just pack up, and watch a movie-"

"Stop it princess. We love it." Leo said interrupting me.

"Really?" I asked as I stared up at them.

"Yeah angel, this is amazing!" Oliver said.

I beamed.

"I'm so glad you like it." I said.

"I'm just glad I didn't ruin it. This isn't what I was expecting when you said you wanted to plan a date for us." Leo said as he joined me on the blanket.

"Imagine how much better it would have been if you didn't force me to tell you about it at all." I replied.

Leo wrapped his arm around my waist, and pulled me right into his lap.

"Don't get mouthy princess." He said.

"Or what?" I asked teasingly.

Leo brought his lips to my ear. "One."

A shiver ran down my spine.

"Babe, you really got all my favorites." Oliver said as he looked through the take out boxes.

I smiled at him. "I hope you're hungry." I said.

Oliver started opening up containers, and setting them in the middle of all of us. He passed out forks, and declared that we should all share everything. I am totally down for that. We made conversation while we ate.

"I can't believe you did all of this for us." Oliver said.

I shrugged. "It wasn't hard. Thankfully, Lila was able to help me a lot." I said really stressing it.

"Remind me to thank her." Leo said, and then kissed my cheek.

I looked up at him. "Oh, I will." I said.

"Do you have anything else planned cupcake? Any.. fun surprises?" Milo asked.

I giggled, and shook my head.

"Just that we all get to spend the night here." I said.

"Damn, Atlas should have made brownies." Milo said.

I laughed. "Uhm, actually, I may, or may not have had Caleb buy me a joint for tonight." I said.

All three sets of eyes snapped to me. I didn't even want to look up to see Leo's face. I gave them all an awkward smile.

"We're getting laid tonight." Milo said before putting a forkful of rice into his mouth.

I snorted. Atlas's eyes clouded as he stared at me. Oliver rested his hand on my bare thigh as he looked at me with the same heat Atlas is. Leo rested his hands on my hips. "M-maybe we can all be together tonight?" I asked.

All eyes looked above me. I turned my head up to look at Leo as well. Leo looked down at me, and smirked, making that lip ring pull up.

"Maybe if you're a good girl princess." He said lowly with that deep voice.

"Feel like I would have better luck, if I was a naughty girl." I mumbled.

Leo chuckled at me. "Risk what you want baby. I can still have fun while not f*****g you. I think we made that clear at this house once before." He said.

Heat spread throughout my body.

"Babygirl, want me to sing to you?" Atlas asked.

I nodded enthusastically.

Atlas pulled his guitar into his lap, and started playing. I leaned against Leo as I listened to Atlas sing to me. I love his voice. I'm also pretty sure he only did this to distract me from being naughty.

I can't stop thinking about it though. Is tonight finally going to be the night that I have all of them together? How is it even going to work?

With how many rounds I go with just two of them, I assume it going to be a whole of touching, and a whole lot of taking turns. All I know is, it doesn't matter if I'm good, or naughty. I will be getting what I want tonight.

"You have such an amazing voice Atlas. Let's put you on a singing show. Your looks alone would get you far." I told him.

"I thought you wanted me to go to culinary school?" Atlas asked with a laugh.

"I want you to do whatever makes you happy." I said.

Atlas gave me my favorite lopsided smile. "Cupcake, come swim with me." Milo said.

He stood up, and stripped his shirt off.

"But you don't have trunks on." I said.

Milo smirked as he undid his shorts.

"No one's around. I can go in my underwear. Or, we can go naked." He offered.

My face heated. I smiled dreamily. I wonder if the others would join us.

"Remember, good girl." Leo whispered in my ear.

I sighed, and stood up. I shimmied out of my little cover. Then Milo grabbed my hand, and practically dragged me to the water.

"You gonna run in with me? Or are you gonna be a chicken?" Milo teased.

I pushed on his chest hard, and took off into the water. Milo joined me almost immediately. We splashed, and played together for a little while. Then Milo grabbed me, and pulled me to his chest. I wrapped my legs around his waist, and my arms around his neck. "I love this suit on you." Milo said as his eyes traveled down my body.

I giggled. "That's why I wore it." I said.

"Ya know what would look even better?" Milo asked me.

"What's that?" I asked.

Milo played with the ties on the sides of my bottoms.

"If we take it off." He said lowly.

A shiver ran down my spine, but I never looked away from Milo. He's daring me with his deep blue eyes. Milo always has a way of hypnotizing me.

"Do it then." I challenged.

Without hesitation, Milo untied both of my ties. He pulled the fabric from my body, and tossed it towads the shore. Then his hands moved to the back of my top. Milo untied the tie around my back, and my neck. Then he threw that piece of clothing towards the shore as well. "Hmmm, it's kind of nice to swim naked." I said.

Milo nodded with his eyes on my bare body under the water. His hands left me to take off his one artical of clothing. I giggled at him. Milo turned me around so that I'm staring at our others on the beach.

Oliver is watching us with a michievious smile on his handsome face. Atlas and Leo are talking. Every once in a while their eyes flicker to us, but I don't think they've realized that we got naked.

"Let me fuck you in the ocean Millie." Milo whispered in my ear as his hands came down to my p***y. "It's always been a dream of mine." He said as his fingers circled my clit.

"Do it. Please daddy." I begged.

Milo kissed the side of my neck. He moved his fingers, and lifted my hips. I kept my eyes on Oliver as Milo slammed me down on his hard c**k. I moaned.

Oliver raised a brow at me as Milo started to bounce me slowly. I wiggled more on Milo, trying to get him to go faster. I whimpered when Milo wouldn't give me what I wanted.

"You don't want Leo to see you being a naughty girl, do you?" Milo whispered.

"Please, he already knows." I said as I slammed myself onto him.

I raised a hand out of the water to beckon Oliver to come in. Milo is still moving me slowly as Oliver stood up. Oliver stripped out of his clothes completely. His d**k is hard as a rock as he walks into the water. Atlas noticed, but Leo did not. I'm not really about to get away with this, am I?

"You wanted me?" Oliver asked once he reached us.

I looked at Oliver, and back to the boys on the beach. Atlas is trying to give Leo his attention, but I can see he is distracted. Leo noticed Oliver in the water, but I still don't think he knows we're naked. I looked back at Oliver. "Fuck me Oliver."